Hate Speech in the Media Discourse of Belarus After the 2020 Presidential Election
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18778/1427-9657.13.02Keywords:
hate speech, mass media, media discourse, Belarusian society, split of societyAbstract
The subject of this paper is an analysis of the use of hate speech in the media discourse of Belarus in the context of social polarisation against the backdrop of a political crisis after the presidential election in 2020. The authors consider the concept of hate speech, referring to various approaches to its interpretation. The widespread use of hate speech reflects deep internal contradictions within the Belarusian society and a split based on different values. The study analysed the contents of some Belarusian Internet media, TV channels, and social media, which utilised techniques such as the denigration, dehumanisation, or marginalisation of certain groups or individuals. Researchers pay special attention to the different directions in which hate speech is used, distinguishing between domestic and foreign political contexts. In the domestic political context, hate speech in Belarus has heightened social instability and polarised the society. In contrast, in the foreign political context, hate speech has worked to construct the image of an external enemy, serving as a tool aimed at consolidating the Belarusian society and mobilising it against external threats. The political crisis specifically served as a catalyst for social tension within the society, leading to the active use of hate speech. Aimed at inciting hatred and intolerance, such materials pose a potential threat to public safety and social stability in the Belarusian society.
References
2 goda kolonii za to, chto upal na nogu karatelya. 2021. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live. https://t.me/nexta_live/12765 (accessed: 02.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Aleksandr Lukashenko nazval protestuyushhih “prokolotoj narkotikami” tolpoj. 2020, https://mediazona.by/news/2020/10/27/drugs (accessed: 25.03.2022).
Google Scholar
Aleksej Dzermant o vystuplenii Prezidenta na VNS: zametil, chto u nego ochen celnoe mirovozzrenie. 2021, http://www.ctv.by/aleksey-dzermant-o-vystuplenii-prezidenta-na-vns-zametil-chto-u-nego-ochen-celnoe-mirovozzrenie (accessed: 18.03.2022).
Google Scholar
Aleshko-Lessels, O., Eliseev, A. 2021. Diskreditaciya politicheskih opponentov v belorusskih gosudarstvennyh SMI i ritorika nenavisti, https://isans.org/columns/diskreditacziya-politicheskih-opponentov-v-belorusskih-gosudarstvennyh-smi-i-ritorika-nenavisti.html (accessed: 02.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Astapenya, R. 2021. Socialnyj raskol v Belarusi i ego posledstviya, https://sapere.online/sotsialnyj-raskol-v-belarusi-i-ego-posledstviya/ (accessed: 01.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Azaryonok: nam obyavlena vojna. 2021, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=snMC7Ptk8Zs&t=66s (accessed: 05.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Baranec: v sluchae voennoj ugrozy ot obektov v Polshe ostanetsya odin shheben. 2019, https://sputnik.by/radio/20190613/1041575010/Baranets-v-sluchae-voennoy-ugrozy-ot-obektov-v-Polshe-ostanetsya-odin-scheben.html (accessed: 30.03.2022).
Google Scholar
Belarus zhyve! 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/10064?single (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Belorusy bedneyut s kazhdym dnem nahozhdeniya uzurpatora u vlasti. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/11389 (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Boguslavskaya, A. 2019. Arhipelag Belarus: kak preodolet raskol v belorusskom obshhestve, https://www.dw.com/ru/%D0%B0%D1%80%D1%85%D0%B8%D0%BF%D0%B5%D0%BB%D0%B0%D0%B3-беларусь-как-преодолеть-раскол-в-белорусском-обществе/a-48025434 (accessed: 01.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Bukvalno gory cvetov i zapisok. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/8062 (accessed: 03.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Chatham House. Vzglyady belorusov na politicheskij krizis. 2021, https://drive.google.com/file/d/1LMW32mEgEP-Fk9CrqYyJpWt7nzjQFhAR/view (accessed: 30.03.2022).
Google Scholar
CHu! 17/10 – Marsh molodosti. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/11724 (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Deneg net, no vy derzhites. 2021, Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/15177 (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Eliseev, A. 2020, Antibelorusskaya propaganda i yazyk vrazhdy: Rezultaty monitoringa toksichnyh pablikov seti “VKontakte”. ISANS, https://isans.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/vkontakte_research.pdf (accessed: 01.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Eliseev, A. 2020, “Zmagary” kak universalnoe vyrazhenie zla: Belorusskaya propaganda osedlala davnij prokremlevskij yarlyk, https://isans.org/articles/zmagary-kak-universalnoe-vyrazhenie-zla-belorusskaya-propaganda-osedlala-davnij-prokremlevskij-yarlyk.html (accessed: 03.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Fashisty brutalno kuda-to tashhat devushek s BCHB. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/11021 (accessed: 20.03.2022).
Google Scholar
Geopolitika ot lukavogo. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/12377 (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Grigorij Azaryonok: esli do vyhodnyh kto eshhe veril v mirnye. 2020, http://www.ctv.by/novosti-minska-i-minskoy-oblasti/grigoriy-azaryonok-esli-do-vyhodnyh-kto-eshchyo-veril-v-mirnye (accessed: 03.04.2022).
Google Scholar
GUBOP priznal svoyu bespomoshhnost. 2021. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/14860 (accessed: 03.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Hate speech. 2013. Cambridge Dictionary, https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/hate-speech (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Iniciativa BYPOL opublikovala novye videosvidetelstva izdevatelstv lukashistskogo gestapo nad belorusami. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/12485 (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Ioffe, G. 2021. Belorusskoe obshhestvo uzhe davno zhivet v usloviyah raskola, https://thinktanks.by/publication/2021/03/01/belorusskoe-obschestvo-uzhe-davno-zhivet-v-usloviyah-raskola.html (accessed: 01.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Izvrashhency, ubijcy, pedofily, gryaznye lzhecy, psihopaty, sadomity, terroristy, prostitutki. Vypusk ot 30 oktyabrya 2021 CTVBY. 2021, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YCanPGxF084 (accessed: 05.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Kiklewicz, A., Pociechina, H. 2021. Yazykovaya kreativnost protestnyh diskursov v Belorussii posle prezidentskih vyborov 2020 goda. Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski 12(1), pp. 269–304, https://doi.org/10.31648/pw.6476; http://www.uwm.edu.pl/cbew/PW_2021_12_1.pdf#page=269 (accessed: 01.04.2022).
Google Scholar
DOI: https://doi.org/10.31648/pw.6476
Kozhevnikova, G. 2006. Yazyk vrazhdy: tipologiya oshibok zhurnalist, https://www.sova-center.ru/hate-speech/publications/2006/12/d9803/ (accessed: 05.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Lica protesta. CHto proishodit v zakrytyh chatah sejchas? // Azaryonok. Tajnye pruzhiny politiki. 2021, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BzxuArt0G5Q&ab_channel=CTVBY (accessed: 05.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Lukashenko: Majdanov v Belarusi ne budet. Hochu predupredit vseh jetih «majdanutyh». 2020, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DPfxfpHg-h0&ab_channel=%D0%A2%D0%B5%D0%BB%D0%B5%D0%BA%D0%B0%D0%BD%D0%B0%D0%BB%D0%9E%D0%9D%D0%A2 (accessed: 03.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Lukashenko namerenno obostryaet otnosheniya s Ukrainoj. 2021. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/14030 (accessed: 03.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Lukashenko o prizyvah k zabastovkam na predpriyatiyah. 2020, https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:0z9_3qBq5iEJ:https://www.belta.by/president/view/lukashenko-o-prizyvah-k-zabastovkam-na-predprijatijah-esli-ostanovimsja-nikogda-ne-raskrutim-svoe-402832-2020/+&cd=3&hl=uk&ct=clnk&gl=pl (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Lukashenko: sidyashhie za rubezhom “zmagary” prodolzhayut izobretat novye kozni protiv nashego gosudarstva. 2020, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bD2cbMyiak8 (accessed: 05.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Lukashenko: vybory proshli kak prazdnik, no te, kto zahotel ego isportit, zasvetilis eshhe yarche. 2020, https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:wCWmKptoGIoJ:https://www.belta.by/president/view/lukashenko-vybory-proshli-kak-prazdnik-no-te-kto-zahotel-ego-isportit-zasvetilis-esche-jarche-402288-2020/+&cd=1&hl=uk&ct=clnk&gl=pl (accessed: 01.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Manaev, O. 2013. Raskol obshhestva – glavnaya istoricheskaya vina Lukashenko, https://www.dw.com/ru/%D0%BE%D0%BB%D0%B5%D0%B3-манаев-раскол-общества-главная-историческая-вина-лукашенко/a-16971899 (accessed: 04.03.2022).
Google Scholar
Manipulyacii vsegda horosho rabotayut, kogda est akcent na jemociyah. 2021, https://mediaiq.by/article/manipulyacii-vsegda-horosho-rabotayut-kogda-est-akcent-na-emociyah-zarubezhnyy-mediaekspert (accessed: 03.03.2022).
Google Scholar
Marsh sosedej. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/12283 (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Marshi v Voskresene. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/12326 (accessed: 31.03.2022).
Google Scholar
Mochi kozlov! Mochi ublyudkov! 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/11654 (accessed: 03.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Monitoring yazyka vrazhdy v SMI Belarusi v otnoshenii lyudej iz uyazvimyh grupp v kontekste pervoj volny pandemii koronavirusa. 2020, https://j4t.info/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Monitoring-yazyika-vrazhdyi-v-SMI-Belarusi-v-otnoshenii-lyudei---iz-uyazvimyih-grupp-v-kontekste-pervoi---volnyi-pandemii-koronavirusa.pdf (accessed: 02.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Na liniyu 102 postupil zvonok iz toj samoj kvartiry. Jeksklyuziv ot Grigoriya Azaryonka. 2021, https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=133&v=wq4LwMPkzGk&feature=emb_title (accessed: 05.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Nasha rodnaya, bratskaya Ukraina sdelala ne takoj vybor, kak my. Mnenie Grigoriya Azaryonka. 2020, http://www.ctv.by/nasha-rodnaya-bratskaya-ukraina-sdelala-ne-takoy-vybor-kak-my-mnenie-grigoriya-azarenka (accessed: 29.03.2022).
Google Scholar
Nedelyu nazad Tarakan obeshhal opublikovat vsyu pravdu o slityh razgovorah lyudej iz ego svity. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/12280 (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Neveroyatnye na polskih polyah: god nazad vyhodili na ulicy, a teper sobirayut klubniku. Panorama. 2021, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=elAvC8H8Aeg (accessed: 05.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Neveroyatnyj zmagar. 2021, https://mediaiq.by/article/neveroyatnyy (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Obkurennye, pyanyh mnogo, s narkotikami: Lukashenko vyskazalsya o protestuyushhih v Minske. 2020, https://esquire.ru/news/politics-news/11-08-2020/199033-obkurennye-pyanyh-mnogo-s-narkotikami-lukashenko-vyskazalsya-o-protestuyushchih-v-minske/ (accessed: 30.03.2022).
Google Scholar
Ozverevshij yabatka izbil parnya za BCHB-flag. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_tv/7744 (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Po dannym pravozashhitnogo centra “Vesna”, na dannyj moment izvestno o 83 zaderzhannyh na Marshe narodnogo obvineniya. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/12432 (accessed: 04 04.2022).
Google Scholar
Po sledam vcherashnego strima predlagaem nebolshuyu jekskursiyu po hramu tshheslaviya lukavogo – Dvorcu Nezavisimosti. 2021. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/13431?single (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Policai budut usilenno zachishhat ulicy Minska. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/12198 (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Polsha uproshhaet usloviya priema na rabotu belorusov. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/12322 (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Posohin, I. 2020. Poslevybornaya situaciya v Belarusi: yazyk i obrazy. In: A.D. Ahvanderova, O.A. Dimitrieva (eds.), Aktualnye problemy prepodavaniya nacionalnyh yazykov i literatur: sb. nauchnyh statej po itogam Mezhdunarodnoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii, posvyashhennoj 70-letiyu kandidata pedagogicheskih nauk, docenta Z.N. Yakushkinoj. Cheboksary, Rossiya, pp. 258–264.
Google Scholar
Prostite, tut ded chto-to nesvyaznoe pro nash kanal skazat pytaetsya. 2021. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/13966 (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Prosto poslushajte, chto govoryat prostye minchanki probegayushhim mimo karatelyam. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/12434 (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Provodim rejdy po vsem naselyonnym punktam regiona s celyu vyyavleniya negosudarstvennoj simvoliki – tajnaya zapis soveshhaniya rukovodstva upravleniya MCHS po Vitebskoj oblasti. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/12453 (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Pytki OMONa. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live. 2020, https://t.me/nexta_live/11178 (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Raskol. Opros. Nezavisimyj institut socialno-jekonomicheskih i politicheskih issledovanij. 1998, http://www.iiseps.org/?p=3174 (accessed: 01.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Recommendation No. R (97) 20 of the Committee of Ministers to Member States on “hate speech”. 1997, https://rm.coe.int/1680505d5b (accessed: 31.03.2022).
Google Scholar
Rezolyuciya Evroparlamenta ugrozhaet budushhemu Evropy. 2020, https://sputnik.by/columnists/20190923/1042804281/Rezolyutsiya-Evroparlamenta-ugrozhaet-buduschemu-Evropy.html (accessed: 31.03.2022).
Google Scholar
Rusofobiya i antisemitizm idut ruka ob ruku. 2020, https://sputnikby/columnists/20200124/1043778629/Rusofobiya-i-antisemitizm-idut-ruka-ob-ruku.html (accessed: 31.03.2022).
Google Scholar
Segodnya bojcu MMA… 2021. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/14447?single (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Segodnya pervoe voskresene... 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/12580?single (accessed: 03.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Segodnya v Minske karateli ustroili potasovku s pensionerami. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/12246?single (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Sergeev: soyuz Belarusi i Rossii – flagman novogo civilizacionnogo processa. 2019, https://sputnik.by/video/20190726/1042200971/Sergeev-belorussko-rossiyskiy-Soyuz--flagman-novogo-tsivilizatsionnogo-protsessa.html (accessed: 19.03.2022).
Google Scholar
Stalo izvestno o gibeli 31-letnego Romana Bondarenko. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/12109 (accessed: 02.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Ukraina, nasha slavyanskaya sestra, otkryla protiv nas front vrazhdy i nenavisti. Mnenie Grigoriya Azaryonka. 2020, http://www.ctv.by/ukraina-nasha-slavyanskaya-sestra-otkryla-protiv-nas-front-2021vrazhdy-i-nenavisti-mnenie-grigoriya (accessed: 30.03.2022).
Google Scholar
V seti poyavilos video, na kotorom otbityj yabatka… 2021. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/13489 (accessed: 03.04.2022).
Google Scholar
V Zhlobine byla sovershena provokaciya… 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/8965?single (accessed: 03.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Vasilenko, E. 2019. “Yazyk vrazhdy” kak predmet nauchnogo analiza i kak socialnyj fenomen (teoreticheskoe obosnovanie perspektiv issledovaniya). Filologiya i chelovek 4, pp. 136–145.
Google Scholar
Vasilenko, E. 2019. Genderno obuslovlennyj “yazyk vrazhdy” v Belarusi: faktory i specifika. Filologichni studiyi 20, pp. 21–28.
Google Scholar
Volyu Belorusov ne slomit. 2020. Telegram-kanal NEXTA Live, https://t.me/nexta_live/12240 (accessed: 04.04.2022).
Google Scholar
Yazyk vrazhdy i nekorrektnaya leksika v belarusskih media. 2021, https://mediaiq.by/search?search_api_views_fulltext=%D1%8F%D0%B7%D1%8B%D0%BA+%D0%B2%D1%80%D0%B0%D0%B6%D0%B4%D1%8B+ (accessed: 28.02.2022).
Google Scholar
Yazyk vrazhdy v Mogilevskoj oblasti. Pervyj kvartal 2017 (monitoring pressy). 2017, https://mspring.media/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/hate-speech-1-kv.pdf (accessed: 28.02.2022).
Google Scholar
Yazyk vrazhdy. Obozrenie Mogilevskoj regionalnoj pressy za 2016 god. 2017, https://mspring.media/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/Oboz-2016.pdf (accessed: 28.02.2022).
Google Scholar
Zhestokie ubijcy, terroristy, nasilniki, geroi belomajdana. 2020, https://www.sb.by/articles/zhestokie-ubiytsy-terroristy-nasilniki-geroi-belomaydana.html (accessed: 02.02.2022).
Google Scholar
Zlochyny na grunti nenavisti: poperedzhennya ta reaguvannya. Informacijno-dovidkovij posibnik dlya gromadskih organizacij u regioni OBSYe.m. 2009, https://www.osce.org/files/f/documents/e/3/180336.pdf (accessed: 18.02.2022).
Google Scholar
Zmei i krysy, pauki i zhaby. Zachem Azaryonku slovar po zoologii? 2021, https://mediaiq.by/article/zmei-i-krysy-pauki-i-zhaby-zachem-azaryonku-slovar-po-zoologii (accessed: 19.02.2022).
Google Scholar
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Taras Polovyi, Khrystyna Yuskiv

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

