The Distant Origins of “Fat Shaming” or why the People of Antiquity did not Ridicule Fat Women

Michał Stachura

doi:10.18778/2084-140X.12.36

Autor

Michał Stachura Uniwersytet Jagielloński https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5276-5951

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.18778/2084-140X.12.36

Słowa kluczowe:

fat shaming, history of mentalities, ancient literature, 19th-century literature, Prodikos, tryphé

Abstrakt

The phenomenon of “fat shaming” (in particular with its aspect of the especially harsh criticism of the corpulence in young adult women) seems nearly non-existent in the ancient Classical literature. The extant satirical depictions of fatness are uncommon and aimed, almost exclusively, at overweight men. The author of the paper analyses this satirical description, its background in the ancient moral philosophy, as well as comments on plumpness and gluttony in the context of assessments of the female physical beauty. He also attempts to explain how some ancient ideas may have evolved in the attitudes of today, showing some examples from the 19th-century prose as a step in the reshaping of the ancient ideas. Eventually, the author makes an attempt to offer a better understanding of this contemporary phenomenon, which only in some of its elements may be seen as rooted in Antiquity.

Pobrania

Brak dostępnych danych do wyświetlenia.

Bibliografia

Agatharchides von Knidos, [in:] Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker, vol. II.1, Zeitgeschichte. A. Universalgeschichte und Hellenika. Texte, ed. F. Jacoby, Berlin 1926, p. 205–222.
Google Scholar

Aristophanes, Comoedias, vol. I–II, ed. Th. Bergk, Lipsiae 1897–1900.
Google Scholar

Athenaeus, The Deipnosophists, ed., trans. Ch. Burton Gulick, London–New York 1927–1941.
Google Scholar

Basilius Caesareae Cappadociae episcopus, Homilia de legendis gentilium libris [in:] Patrologiae cursus completus, Series graeca, vol. XXXI, ed. J.-P. Migne, Paris 1857, col. 564–590.
Google Scholar

C. Suetonii Tranquilli De vita Caesarum libri VIII, rec. M. Ihm, Lipsiae 1907.
Google Scholar

Claudii Aeliani De natura animalium libri xvii, varia historia, epistolae, fragmenta, vol. II, rec. R. Hercher, Lipsiae 1866.
Google Scholar

D. Iunii Iuvenalis Saturae, ed. A. Weidner, Leipzig 1873.
Google Scholar

Dio’s Roman History, ed., trans. E. Cary, London–Harvard 1954–1961.
Google Scholar

Eusebius, Die Kirchengeschichte, [in:] Eusebius, Werke, vol. II, ed. E. Schwartz, Th. Mommsen, Lipsiae 1902–1909 [= Die griechischen christlichen Schriftsteller der ersten [drei] Jahrhunderte, 9].
Google Scholar

Galen, On the Constitution of the Art of Medicine. The Art of Medicine. A Method of Medicine to Glaucon, ed., trans. I. Johnston, Cambridge Mass. 2016 [= Loeb Classical Library, 523], https://doi.org/10.4159/DLCL.galen-method_medicine_glaucon.2016
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.4159/DLCL.galen-method_medicine_glaucon.2016

Ioannis Zonarae Epitome Historiarum, ed. L. Dindorf, Lipsiae 1868–1875, https://doi.org/10.1515/9783112422489
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/9783112422489

Iohannes Chrysostomus, Homilia XXIX in Epistulam I ad Corinthios, [in:] Patrologiae cursus completus, Series graeca, vol. LXI, ed. J. P. Migne, Paris 1962, col. 332–347.
Google Scholar

Iohannes Chrysostomus, Homilia XXVII in Acta apostolorum, [in:] Patrologiae cursus completus, Series graeca, vol. LX, ed. J. P. Migne, Paris 1962, col. 203–210.
Google Scholar

L. Annaei Senecae ad Lucilium epistolarum moralium quae supersunt, ed. O. Hense, Lipsiae 1898.
Google Scholar

L. Caelius Firmianus Lactantius, De mortibus persecutorum, ed. et trans. J. L. Creed, Oxford 1984.
Google Scholar

Lucan, The Civil War, ed., trans. J. D. Duff, London–Cambridge Mass. 1977.
Google Scholar

Lukian, Werke, vol. I–III, ed. J. Werner, H. Greiner Mai, trans. Ch.M. Wieland, Berlin 1981.
Google Scholar

M. Tulli Ciceronis De Officiis, ed. C. Atzert, Lipsiae 1963.
Google Scholar

Marcus Tullius Cicero, Scripta quae manserunt omnia, Fasc. 6, In L. Sergium Catilinam orationes, ed. P. Reis, Lipsiae 1933.
Google Scholar

Marcus Tullius Cicero, Scripta quae manserunt omnia, Fasc. 28, In M. Antonium orationes Philippicae XIV, ed. P. Fedeli, Lipsiae 1986 [= Bibliotheca scriptorum Graecorum et Romanorum Teubneriana], https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110957631
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110957631

M. Valerii Martialis Epigramaton Libri, rec. W. Heraeus, ed. corr. L. Borovskij, Leipzig 1976.
Google Scholar

Ovidius, Ars Ama, [in:] P. Ovidi Nasonis Amores; Medicamina Faciei Femineae; Ars Amatoria; Remedia Amoris, ed. E. J. Kenney, Oxonii 1961 [= Scriptorum Classicorum Bibliotheca Oxoniensis/ Oxford Classical Texts], p. 109–204, https://doi.org/10.1093/oseo/instance.00089820
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/oseo/instance.00089820

Plato, The Republic, ed. J. Adam, Cambridge 1969.
Google Scholar

Plato, Timaios, rec. C. F. Hermann, Lipsiae 1896, p. 319–406.
Google Scholar

Plutarchus, Vitae Paralellae, rec. K. Ziegler, Leipzig 1969–1980.
Google Scholar

Procopius, Historia Arcana, ed. J. Haury, Lipsiae 1963.
Google Scholar

Pseudo-Plutarchus, Regum et imperatorum apophtegmata, [in:] Plutarchus, Moralia, vol. II, ed. W. Nachstädt, W. Sieverking, J. B. Titchener, Leipzig 1971 [= Bibliotheca scriptorum Graecorum et Romanorum Teubneriana], p. 1–109, https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110952636
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110952636

Sancti Eusebii Hieronymi Epistulae, vol. I, rec. I. Hilberg, Vindobonae–Lipsiae 1910.
Google Scholar

Silii Italici Punica, vol. I–II, ed. L. Bauer, Lipsiae 1900–1902.
Google Scholar

Soranos d’Éphèse, Maladies des femmes, vol. I–IV, ed., trans. D. Gourevitch, Paris 2003.
Google Scholar

Vegetius, Epitoma rei militaris, ed. M. D. Reeve, Oxford 2004.
Google Scholar

Xenophon, Memorabilia, ed. W. Gilbert, Lipsiae 1949.
Google Scholar

Brontë Ch., Villette, Ware 1999.
Google Scholar

Dickens Ch., Barnaby Rudge. A Tale of the Riots of Eighty, Auckland 2010.
Google Scholar

Dostoyevsky F., The Brothers Karamazov, trans. C. Garnett, New York 2009.
Google Scholar

de Maupassant G., Boule le Suif, The Dumpling, parallel text, trans. T. Chilcott, 2008, www.tclt.org.uk/maupassant/Boule_de_Suif_2011.pdf, access [14 VI 2022].
Google Scholar

Szymborska W., Rubens’ Women, trans. J. Trzeciak, “The Virginia Quarterly Review” 77.2, 2001, p. 267–268.
Google Scholar

Taylor E., Elisabeth Takes Off. On Weight Gain, Weight Loss, Self-Image & Self-Esteem, London 1988.
Google Scholar

Tolstoy L. N., The Kreutzer Sonata, [in:] The Kreutzer Sonata Variations. Lev Tolstoy Novella and Counterstories by Sofiya Tolstaya and Lev Lvovich Tolstoy, trans. et ed. M. R. Katz, New Haven 2004, p. 3–70, https://doi.org/10.12987/9780300210392-004
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.12987/9780300210392-004

Tolstoy L. N., Resurrection, trans. L. Maude, Oxford 2020.
Google Scholar

Zola E., Nana, trans. B. Rascoe, New York 1922.
Google Scholar

Akimovich I., Hercules at the Crossroads, 1801.
Google Scholar

Baglione G., Hercules chooses between Good and Evil, 1642.
Google Scholar

Balducci M., Hercules at the Crossroads, 15th century.
Google Scholar

Batoni P., Hercules at the Crossroads, 1748.
Google Scholar

Benvenuti P., Hercules at the Crossroads, 1828.
Google Scholar

di Benvenuto G., Hercules at the Crossroads, first half of the 16th century.
Google Scholar

Boucher F., The Choice between Vice and Virtue, Hercules at the Crossroads, c. 1567.
Google Scholar

Caracci A., The Choice of Hercules, 1596.
Google Scholar

Cranach the Elder L., Hercules at the Crossroads, 1537.
Google Scholar

De la Fosse Ch., Hercules at the Crossroads, beginnings of 18th century.
Google Scholar

Dürer A., Hercules at the Crossroads, 1498.
Google Scholar

Hunerbein J., Hercules at the Crossroads, 1595.
Google Scholar

de Lairesse G., Hercules Between Vice and Virtue, 1675.
Google Scholar

de Matteis P., The Choice of Hercules, 1712.
Google Scholar

de Min G., Hercules at the Crossroads, 1812.
Google Scholar

van Mieris Younger F., Hercules at the Crossroads, 1727.
Google Scholar

Poussin N., Hercules at the Crossroads, 1636–1637.
Google Scholar

Ricci S., Hercules at the Crossroads, c. 1710–1720.
Google Scholar

Rubens P. P., Hercules at the Crossroads, 1610.
Google Scholar

Sadaler I J., Hercules at the Crossroads, c. 1590–1600 (copper engraving).
Google Scholar

Soggi N., Hercules at the Crossroads, first half of the 16th century.
Google Scholar

Suly Th., Choice of Hercules, 1819.
Google Scholar

Veronese P., Young Man between Vice and Virtue, c. 1581.
Google Scholar

West B., Choice of Hercules between Virtue and Pleasure, 1764.
Google Scholar

Zelotti G. B., Hercules at the Crossroads, 1561.
Google Scholar

Ager S. L., Familiarity Breeds: Incest and the Ptolemaic Dynasty, “Journal of Hellenic Studies” 125, 2005, p. 1–34, https://doi.org/10.1017/S0075426900007084
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0075426900007084

Bell K., McNaughton D., Salmon A., Introduction, [in:] Alcohol, Tobacco and Obesity. Morality, Mortality, and the New Public Health, ed. K. Bell, D. McNaughton, A. Salmon, London–New York 2011, p. 1–16, https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203822159
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203822159

Blondell R., Helen of Troy. Beauty, Myth, Devastation, Oxford 2013, https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199731602.001.0001
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199731602.001.0001

Bordo S., Unbearable Weight. Feminism, Western Culture, and the Body, Berkely 1993.
Google Scholar

Bradley M., Obesity, Corpulence and Emaciation in Roman Art, “Papers of the British School at Rome” 79, 2011, p. 1–41, https://doi.org/10.1017/S0068246211000018
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0068246211000018

Cameron A., The Later Roman Empire A. D. 384–430, London 1993.
Google Scholar

Chernin K., The Obsession. Reflections on the Tyranny of Slenderness, New York–San Francisco–Toronto 1981.
Google Scholar

Coveney J., In Praise of Hunger: Public Health and the Problem of Excess, [in:] Alcohol, Tobacco and Obesity. Morality, Mortality, and the New Public Health, ed. K. Bell, D. McNaughton, A. Salmon, London–New York 2011, p. 146–160.
Google Scholar

Cozzoli U., La τρυφή nella interpretazione delle crisi politiche, [in:] Tra Grecia e Roma. Temi antichi e metodologie moderne, Roma 1980, p. 133–145.
Google Scholar

Craton L., The Victorian Freek Show. The Significance of Disability and Physical Differences in 19th-Century Fiction, Amherst NY 2009.
Google Scholar

Ehrenberg V., The People of Aristophanes, New York 1962.
Google Scholar

Farrell A. E., Fat Shame. Stigma and the Fat Body in American Culture, New York–London 2011.
Google Scholar

Fisher N., Hybris. A Study in the Values of Honour and Shame in Ancient Greece, Warminster 1992.
Google Scholar

Fleischer R., Hellenistic Royal Iconography on Coins, [in:] Aspects of Hellenistic Kingship. Studies in Hellenistic civilisation, vol. VII, ed. P. Bilde, T. Engberg-Petersen, L. Hannestad, J. Zahle, Aarhus 1996, p. 28–40.
Google Scholar

Gard M., Between Alarmists and Sceptics: on the Cultural Politics of Obesity Scholarship and Public Policy, [in:] Alcohol, Tobacco and Obesity. Morality, Mortality, and the New Public Health, ed. K. Bell, D. McNaughton, A. Salmon, London–New York 2011, p. 59–72.
Google Scholar

Gorman R. J., Gorman V. B., ΤΡΥΦΗ and ΥΒΡΙΣ in the ΠΕΡΙ ΒΙΩΝ of Clearchus, “Philologus” 2, 2010, p. 187–208, https://doi.org/10.1524/phil.2010.0017
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1524/phil.2010.0017

Gourevitch D., L’obésité et son traitement dans le monde romain, “History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences” 7, 1985, p. 195–215.
Google Scholar

Grabowski T., Tryphé w ideologii Ptolomeuszy, [in:] Społeczeństwo i religia w świecie antycznym. Materiały z ogólnopolskiej konferencji naukowej (Toruń 20–22 września 2007), ed. S. Olszaniec, P. Wojciechowski, Toruń 2010, p. 91–107.
Google Scholar

Guggenheim K., Galen of Pergamon on Obesity, “Koroth” 9, 1988, p. 555–556.
Google Scholar

Guggenheim K., Soranos of Ephesos on Obesity, “International Journal of Obesity” 1, 1977, p. 245–246.
Google Scholar

Hartley C., Letting Ourselves go. Making Room for the Fat Body in Feminist Scholarship, [in:] Bodies out of Bounds. Fatness and Transgression, ed. J. E. Braziel, K. LeBesco, Berkeley–Los Angeles–London 2001, p. 60–73.
Google Scholar

Heinen H., Die Tryphè von Ptolemaios VIII Euergetes II. Beobachtungen zum ptolomäischen Herrscherideal und zu einer römischen Gesandtschaft in Ägypten (140/139 v. Chr.), [in:] Althistorische Studien Hermann Bengtson zum 70. Geburtstag dargebracht von Kollegen und Schülern, ed. H. Heinen, K. Stroheker, G. Walser, Wiesbaden 1983, p. 116–128.
Google Scholar

Herter H., Effeminatus, [in:] Reallexikon für Antike und Christentum, vol. IV, ed. Th. Klauser, Stuttgart 1959, p. 619–650.
Google Scholar

Hill S. E., Eating to Excess. The Meaning of Gluttony and The Fat Body in The Ancient World, Santa Barbara 2011.
Google Scholar

Jones B., Teuta and Feminine Exemplarity in Cassius Dio’s Roman History, [in:] Cassius Dio the Historian. Methods and Approaches, ed. J. M. Madsen, C. H. Lange, Leiden 2021, p. 406–425, https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004461604_018
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004461604_018

Karila-Cohen K., Les gourmands grecs sont-ils bien en chair?, [in:] Le corps du gourmand. D’Héraclès à Alexandre le Bienheureux, ed. K. Karila-Cohen, F. Quellier, François-Rabelais de Tours–Rennes 2012, p. 109–132.
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/books.pufr.28730

King I., Study Help. Cleopatra Imagery in 19th Century Novels. Middlemarch and Villette, 2018, https://owlcation.com/humanities/Cleopatra-Imagery-in-19th-Century-English-Novels-Middlemarch-and-Villette [14 VI 2022].
Google Scholar

Klein R., Fat Beauty, [in:] Bodies out of Bounds. Fatness and Transgression, ed. J. E. Braziel, K. LeBesco, Berkeley–Los Angeles–London 2001, p. 19–38.
Google Scholar

Krugovoy Silver A., Victorian Literature and the Anorexic Body, Cambridge 2004.
Google Scholar

Kuntz M., The Prodikean “Choice of Herakles” a Reshaping of Myth, “Classical Journal” 89.2, 1993/1994, p. 163–181.
Google Scholar

Laes Ch., Writing the History of Fatness and Thinness in Graeco-Roman Antiquity, “Medicina nei Secoli: Arte e Scienza” 28.2, 2016, p. 583–658.
Google Scholar

LeBesco K., Neoliberalism, Public Health and the Moral Perils of Fatness, [in:] Alcohol, Tobacco and Obesity. Morality, Mortality, and the New Public Health, ed. K. Bell, D. McNaughton, A. Salmon, London–New York 2011, p. 33–46.
Google Scholar

Marasco G., Marco Antonio « nuovo Dioniso » e il “De sua ebrietate”, “Latomus” 51, 1992, p. 538–548.
Google Scholar

Matthews M., Victorian Fat Shaming. Harsh Words on Weight from the 19th Century, 2016, https://www.mimimatthews.com/2016/04/25/victorian-fat-shaming-harsh-words-on-weight-from-the-19th-century/ [14 VI 2022].
Google Scholar

McNaughton D., From the Womb to the Tomb: Obesity and Maternal Responsibility, [in:] Alcohol, Tobacco and Obesity. Morality, Mortality, and the New Public Health, ed. K. Bell, D. McNaughton, A. Salmon, London–New York 2011, p. 163–176.
Google Scholar

Nadeau R., Héraclès, ce gourmand, [in:] Le corps du gourmand. D’Héraclès à Alexandre le Bienheureux, ed. K. Karila-Cohen, F. Quellier, François-Rabelais de Tours–Rennes 2012, p. 93–108.
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/books.pufr.28725

Panofsky E., Hercules am Scheidewege und andere antike Bildstoffe in der neueren Kunst, Leipzig 1930.
Google Scholar

Papavramidou N., Christopoulou-Aletra H., Greco-Roman and Byzantine Views on Obesity, “Obesity Surgery” 17, 2007, p. 112–116, https://doi.org/10.1007/s11695-007-9017-2
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11695-007-9017-2

Passerini A., La ΤΡΥΦΗ nella storiografia ellenistica, “Studi italiani di filologia classica” 11, 1934, p. 35–56.
Google Scholar

Quellier F., Gourmandise. Histoire d’un péché capital, Paris 2010.
Google Scholar

Stachura M., Enemies of the Later Roman Order. A Study of the Phenomenon of Language Aggression in the Theodosian Code, Post-Theodosian Novels, and the Sirmondian Constitutions, Kraków 2018.
Google Scholar

Stafford E., Vice or Virtue? Herakles and the art of allegory, [in:] Herakles and Hercules. Exploring a Graeco-roman Divinity, ed. L. Rawlings, H. Bowden, Swansea 2005, p. 71–96, https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctv1n357sj.8
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctv1n357sj.8

Tondriau J., La tryphè: philosophie royale ptolémaïque, “Revue des études anciennes” 50, 1948, p. 49–54, https://doi.org/10.3406/rea.1948.3388
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.3406/rea.1948.3388

Vandereycken W., van Deth R., From Fasting Saints to Anorexic Girls. The History of Self Starvation, London 1994.
Google Scholar

Vigarello G., The Metamorphoses of Fat. A History of Obesity, trans. C. J. Delogu, New York 2013 (orig. Les métamorphoses du gras. Histoire de l’obesité. Du Moyen Âge au XXe siècle, Paris 2010).
Google Scholar

Wilgaux J., Gourmands et gloutons dans le sources physiognomoniques antiques, [in:] Le corps du gourmand. D’Héraclès à Alexandre le Bienheureux, ed. K. Karila-Cohen, F. Quellier, François-Rabelais de Tours–Rennes 2012, p. 23–36.
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/books.pufr.28690

Wolf N., The Beauty Myth. How Images of Beauty Are Used Against Women, London 1990.
Google Scholar

Zeppi S., L’etica di Prodicco, “Rivista critica di storia della filosofia” 11, 1956, p. 265–272.
Google Scholar