John Chrysostom’s Tale on How Michael Vanquished Satanael – a Bogomil text?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18778/2084-140X.01.03Abstract
The study is an attempt at a comparative analysis of two pseudo-canonical texts: the Slavic Homily of John Chrysostom on How Michael Vanquished Satanael (in two versions) and the Greek Λόγος τοῠ ἀρχηστρατήγου Μιχαήλ, ὃταν ἐπῆρεν τήν στολήν (BHG 1288n). Both texts, very close to each other in terms of the plot, relate an ancient angelomachia between a heavenly emissary and a demiurge expelled from the angelic hierarchy. When examined against the background of dualistic heterodox doctrines on the one hand, and compared to other medieval cultural texts (be they liturgical, iconographical or folkloric) on the other, these works enable insight into how heterodox and pseudo-canonical texts functioned and were disseminated in the medieval Byzantine-Slavic cultural sphere. The Slavic Homily… is not genetically related to its Greek counterpart, which is only preserved in a lat, 16th century copy. Rather, it was composed before the 13th century on the basis of another, non-extant model with a content similar to the pseudo-canonical Greek Homily… It is probable to a certain degree that the emergence of the Slavic work is connected with the growing interest in the cult of Archangel Michael in the First Bulgarian Empire, especially in the Diocese of Ohrid. Certain Gnostic ideas related to dualistic cosmology, as well as cosmogony, angelology and anthropology spread from the Judeo-Christian world to Byzantine literature and culture. Having undergone a number of transformations in the neo-Manichean communities of the Byzantine Empire and Bulgaria, they formed the basis for medieval dualistic cosmogony, as well as angelology and anthropology. Circulated both orally and in written form, beliefs concerning the invisible God, Archangel Michael as a ‘second God’ and the soul’s journey to Paradise became so widespread that they are not only found in heretic texts, but also cited almost verbatim in anti-heretic treatises. The content and later textual modifications of the Slavic Homily… cast a doubt on the hypothesis concerning its Bogomil origin. Furthermore, it cannot be determined to what extent works such as the Homily… were made use of by (moderate?) Bogomil communities. Even before the 14th century, the text underwent the processes of liturgization and folklorization, as proven by the presence of liturgical quotations (absent from the Greek text), the visualization of the story in sacred space as well as the aetiological legends about Archangel Michael’s fight against the Devil. The existence of ancient Gnostic ideas in the beliefs propagated by neo-Manichean Balkan heretic teachings, as well as their widespread presence in “high” and “low” texts originating in medieval communities call for a more cautious evaluation of the mutual antagonisms between them. This raises the problem of a wider look at medieval culture, in fact a syncretic phenomenon, where the distinction between the canonical, the pseudo-canonical, the heretic and the folkloric is not always clear-cut.
Downloads
References
Ангелов Д., Богомилството в България, София 1981.
Google Scholar
Ангелов Д., Богомилството, София 1993.
Google Scholar
Ангелов Д., Примов Б., Батаклиев Г., Богомилството в България, Византия и Западна Европа в извори, София 1967.
Google Scholar
Апокрифи старозаветни према српским преписима (Стара српска књижевност у 24 књиге, књига 23, 1 том), ed. Т. Jовановић, Београд 2005.
Google Scholar
Apokryfy i legendy starotestamentowe Słowian południowych, ed. G. Minczew, M. Skowronek, Kraków 2006.
Google Scholar
Афиногенова O., Греческий вариант апокрифа о борьбе архангела Михаила и Сатанаила, "Scripta & e-Scripta" 3/4, 2006, p. 329–348.
Google Scholar
Бегунов Ю.К., Козма Пресвитер в славянских литературах, София 1973.
Google Scholar
Българска народна поезия и проза, vol. VII, София 1983.
Google Scholar
Бычков A.T., Описание церковно-славянских и русских рукописных сборников Императорской публичной библиотеки, Санкт-Петербург 1882
Google Scholar
Богдановић Д., Милтенова A., Апокрифният сборник от манастира Савина XIV в. в сравнение с други подобни южнославянски ръкописи, "Археографски прилози" 1, 1987, p. 3–27.
Google Scholar
Christian Dualist Heresies in the Byzantine World c. 650 – c. 1450: Selected Sources, ed. J. Hamilton, B. Hamilton, Y. Stoyanov, Manchester 1998.
Google Scholar
Dlaczego ludzie nie mają płaskich stóp, trans. M. Lewińska, [in:] Apokryfy i legendy starotestamentowe Słowian południowych, ed. G. Minczew, M. Skowronek, Kraków 2006, p. 233.
Google Scholar
Дуйчев И., Из старата българска книжнина, t. I, София 1940.
Google Scholar
Erhard A., Überlieferung und bestand der hagiografischen und homiletischen Literatur der Griechischen Kirchе, vol. III, Leipzig 1937.
Google Scholar
Зашто у људи ниjе табан раван, [in:] В. Чаjкановић, Српске народне приповетке, Београд 1929, no. 162, 2.
Google Scholar
Ficker G., Die Phundagiagiten, Leipzig 1908.
Google Scholar
Габелић C., Лесново, Београд 1998.
Google Scholar
Габелић C., Византиjски и поствизантиjски циклуси арханђела XI–XVIII в., Београд 2004.
Google Scholar
Gabelić S., The Fall of Satan in Byzantine and Post-Byzantine Art, "Зограф" 23, 1993/1994, p. 65–74.
Google Scholar
Гагова H., Владетели и книги. Участието на южнославянския владетел в проиводството и употребата на книги през Средновековието (IX–XV в.): рецепцията на византийския модел, София 2010.
Google Scholar
Gautier P., Le ‘De demonibus’ du Pseudo-Psellos, "Revue des études byzantines" 38, 1980, p. 94–105.
Google Scholar
Gnostic Writings on the Soul: Annotated & Explained, ed. A. P. Smith, Woodstock Ver. 2007.
Google Scholar
Господ и дjаволот го делеле светот, [in:] T. Вражиновски, Народна митологиjа на македонците, vol. II, Скопjе–Прилеп 1998, no. 15.
Google Scholar
Graves R., Patai R., Hebrew Myths. The Book of Genesis, Garden City 1964.
Google Scholar
Heresies of the High Middle Ages, ed. W. Wakefield, A. Evans, New York 1991.
Google Scholar
Irenaeus, Adversus haereses, [in:] Five Books of S. Irenaeus, Bishop of Lyons, Against Heresies, ed. J. Parker, Oxford 1872.
Google Scholar
Иванов Й., Старобългарски разкази, София 1935.
Google Scholar
Иванов Й., Богомилски книги и легенди, ed. photot., София 1970.
Google Scholar
Ivanov J. Siedem niebios i ziemia. Antologia dawnej prozy bułgarskiej, ed. T. Dąbek-Wirgowa, Warszawa 1983.
Google Scholar
Иванова К., О славянском переводе „Паноплии догматики” Евфимия Зигабена, [in:] Исследования по древней и новой литературе, Ленинград 1987, p. 101–105.
Google Scholar
Иванова К., Един литургичен паралел към апокрифа „Как Михаил победи Сатанаил”, [in:] Civitas divina-humana. In honorem annorum LX Georgii Bakalov, София 2004, p. 397–404.
Google Scholar
Jak Święty Archanioł ukradł diabłu słońce, trans. A. Kawecka, [in:] Apokryfy i legendy starotestamentowe Słowian południowych, ed. G. Minczew, M. Skowronek, Kraków 2006, p. 232.
Google Scholar
Јовановић T., Траг апокрифа о борби са ђаволом у српској народној књижевности, "Књижевност и језик" 43.3/4, 1995, p. 33–55.
Google Scholar
Как свети Иван взема от дявола знамето, "Сборник за народни умотворения" 44, 1949, p. 485–486.
Google Scholar
Како jе свети Рангел украо сунце од ђавола, [in:] Српски Етнографски Зборник, vol. CXIV.4, Српске народне приповетке и предања из Лесковачке области, ed. Д.М. Ђорђевић, Београд 1988, no. 49, p. 468–469.
Google Scholar
Каlužniacki E., Werke des Patriarchen von Bulgarien Euthymius (1375–1393), London 1971.
Google Scholar
Милтенова A., Апокрифът за борбата на архангел Михаил със Сатанаил в две редакции, "Старобългарска литература" 9, 1981, p. 98–113.
Google Scholar
Милтенова A., Неизвестна редакция на апокрифа за борбата на Архангел Михаил със Сатанаил, [in:] Литературознание и фолклористика. Сборник в чест на акад. Петър Динеков, София 1983, p. 121–128.
Google Scholar
Милтенова A., Слово за лъжливия Антихрист, [in:] Старобългарска литература. Енциклопедичен речник, ed. Д. Петканова, Велико Търново 2003, p. 466.
Google Scholar
Мошин B., Ћирилски рукописи у манастиру Никољцу код Биjелог поља, "Историjски записи. Орган Историjског института НР Црне горе" 18, 1961, p. 704.
Google Scholar
O tym, jak Pan Bóg i diabeł dzielili świat, trans. A. Kawecka, [in:] Apokryfy i legendy starotestamentowe Słowian południowych, ed. G. Minczew, M. Skowronek, Kraków 2006, p. 228.
Google Scholar
Петканова Д., Апокрифна литература и фолклор, София 1978.
Google Scholar
Попов A., Книга Бытия небеси и земли, Санкт-Петербург 1881.
Google Scholar
Порфирьев И.Я., Апокрифические сказания о ветхозаветных лицах и событиях, Санкт- Петербург 1877.
Google Scholar
Quispel G., Gnosis als Weltreligion, Zürich 1951.
Google Scholar
Rudolph K., Gnosis. The Nature and History of Gnosticism, trans. R. McLachlan Wilson, San Francisco 1983.
Google Scholar
Skowronek M., „Świat cały ma Cię za obrońcę”. Michał Archanioł w kulturze Słowian prawosławnych na Bałkanach, Łódź 2008.
Google Scholar
Стара българска литература в седем тома, vol. I, Апокрифи, ed. Д. Петканова, София 1982.
Google Scholar
Стефанов П., Ялдаваот. История и учение на гностическата религия, София 2008.
Google Scholar
Стоянов Ю., Другият бог. Дуалистичните религии от Античността до катарската ерес, София 2006.
Google Scholar
Tajemna księga, czyli Zapytania Jana zadane w wieczerniku Królowi niebieskiemu, trans. A. Sarwa, [in:] A. Sarwa, Tajemna księga katarów, Sandomierz 2006.
Google Scholar
Трофимова M.K., Историко-философские вопросы гностицизма, Москва 1979.
Google Scholar
Цар Дуклjан и Крститељ Jован, [in:] В. Караџић, Српске народне пjесме, vol. II, Београд 1985, no. 17, p. 67–69.
Google Scholar
Чешмеджиев Д., Към въпроса за култа на княз Борис-Михаил в средновековна България, "Исторически преглед" 1999, 3/4, p. 158–176.
Google Scholar
Успенский Б.А., Филологические разыскания в области славянских древностей, Москва 1982.
Google Scholar
Vasiliev A., Anecdota graeco-byzantina, Москва 1892.
Google Scholar
Widzenie, które miał Święty Izajasz prorok, syn Amosa, trans. I. Petrov, [in:] Apokryfy i legendy starotestamentowe Słowian południowych, ed. G. Minczew, M. Skowronek, Kraków 2006, p. 53–61.
Google Scholar
Wisse F., [in:] The Nag Hammadi Library, ed. J.M. Robinson, San Francisco 1990.
Google Scholar
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.