Reception of John V. A. Fine Jr.’s The Bosnian Church: A New Interpretation: Interesting Sleeve of a Never Ending Historiographical Debate

Dženan Dautović

doi:10.18778/2084-140X.12.04

Authors

Dženan Dautović Regional museum Travnik – Faculty of Philosophy Tuzla, Šehida 17, 72270 Travnik, Bosnia and Herzegovina https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7858-3977

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.18778/2084-140X.12.04

Keywords:

Bosnian Church, John V. A. Fine Jr., heresy, medieval Bosnia, historiography

Abstract

Historiography about the medieval Bosnian Church is a vast and complicated labyrinth, with many different sections and subsections regarding its teachings, where authors are least likely to find a compromise, or some common ground. Very often, the ruling ideologies have intertwined their interests and influences in this field of medieval study, causing the emergence of very intense emotions in wider circles of population. One remarkable episode in history of research and study of the Bosnian Church is the occurrence of medievalist from United States of America, John V. A. Fine Jr., who arrived in Bosnia and Yugoslavia at the peak of the Cold War. Fine proved to be a very meticulous researcher, who produced a book under the title: The Bosnian Church: A New Interpretation. A Study of the Bosnian Church and its Place in State and Society from the 13th to the 15th Centuries which immediately caused disturbance and wide range of reactions. With his aligning with the historiographical stream which doesn’t see the Bosnian Church as a dualistic heretical institution, rather a monastic community independent from both of the big churches of the time, Fine gave additional fuel to this theory, a theory somewhat weakened in that period as its main protagonist Jaroslav Šidak had a change of mind. The main goal of this paper is to study the immediate reactions on Fine’s thesis, in forms of reviews of his book, as well its influence in the subsequent decades of the historiographical studies of the Bosnian Church.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Ćirković S., Bosanska crkva u bosanskoj državi, [in:] Prilozi za istoriju Bosne i Hercegovine I. Društvo i privreda srednjovjekovne bosanske države, ed. E. Redžić, Sarajevo 1987, p. 195–254.
Google Scholar

Ćirković S., O istoriografiji i metodologiji, Beograd 2007, p. 208–209.
Google Scholar

Ćošković P., Četvrt stoljeća historiografije o Crkvi bosanskoj, [in:] Istorijska nauka o Bosni i Hercegovini u razdoblju 1990–2000, ed. E. Redžić, Sarajevo 2003, p. 31–54.
Google Scholar

Ćošković P., Crkva bosanska u XV. stoljeću, Sarajevo 2005.
Google Scholar

Ćošković P., Ogledanje krivnje u srednjovjekovnoj bosanskoj državi, [in:] Bogišić i kultura sjećanja, ed. J. Kregar, Zagreb 2011, p. 338–356.
Google Scholar

Ćošković P., Tomašev progon sljedbenika Crkve bosanske 1459., [in:] Migracije i Bosna i Hercegovina, Sarajevo 1990, p. 43–48.
Google Scholar

Dautović Dž., Crkva bosanska i stećci, “Historijska misao” 6, 2020, p. 11–44, https://doi.org/10.51558/2303-8543.2021.6.6.11
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.51558/2303-8543.2021.6.6.11

Dautović Dž., Crkva bosanska: moderni historiografski tokovi, rasprave i kontroverze (2005–2015), “Historijska traganja” 15, 2015, p. 127–160.
Google Scholar

Dautović Dž., Novi prilozi poznavanju vjerskih prilika srednjovjekovne Bosne u inostranoj historiografiji, “Bosna franciscana” 48, 2018, p. 203–212.
Google Scholar

Dautović Dž., Regio nullius dioecesis: kako je Bosna ostala bez biskupije? Procesi i posljedice, [in:] Prijelomne godine bosanskohercegovačke prošlosti (I), ed. S. Bešlija, Sarajevo 2021, p. 75–92.
Google Scholar

Džaja S. M., Fineova interpretacija bosanske srednjovjekovne konfesionalne povijesti, [in:] Povijesno-teološki simpozij u povodu 500. obljetnice smrti bosanske kraljice Katarine, ed. J. Turčinović, Sarajevo 1979, p. 52–59.
Google Scholar

Džaja S. M., [rec.:] John Fine, The Bosnian Church. Its Place in State and Society from the Thirteenth to the Fifteenth Century. A New Interpretation. London: SAQI in Association with The Bosnian Institute 2007. 426 S., ISBN 978-0-86356-503-8, £ 30, “Südost-Forschungen” 67, 2008, p. 431–435.
Google Scholar

Džaja S. M., [rec.:] Noch eine fragliche Interpretation der bosnischen mittelalterlichen Konfessionsgeschichte, “Münchener Zeitschrift für Balkankunde” 1, 1978, p. 247–254.
Google Scholar

Fine J.V.A. Jr., A Tale of Three Fortresses. Controversies Surrounding the Turkish Conquest of Smederevo, of an Unnamed Fortress at the Junction of the Sava and Bosna, and of Bobovac, [in:] Peace and War in Byzantium. Essays in Honor of George T. Dennis, S. J., ed. T. S. Miller, J. W. Nesbitt, Washington 1995, p. 181–196.
Google Scholar

Fine J.V.A. Jr., Aristodios and Rastudije. A Re-examination of the Question, “Godišnjak Društva istoričara Bosne i Hercegovine” 16, 1965, p. 223–229.
Google Scholar

Fine J.V.A. Jr., Bosanska crkva: novo tumačenje. Studija o Bosanskoj crkvi, njenom mjestu u državi i društvu od 13. do 15. stoljeća, trans. T. Praštalo, Sarajevo 2005.
Google Scholar

Fine J.V.A. Jr., [rec.:] Franjo Šanjek, Les Chrétiens bosniaques et le movement cathare, XIIe–XVe siècles. (Publications de la Sorbonne, N. S. Rechercehes, 20) Brussels, Paris, Louvain: Nauwelaerts, 1976. Paper. Pp. 263; 12 black-and-white plates, 5 maps, 2 illustrations. FB 700, “Speculum” 53, 1978, p. 414–416, https://doi.org/10.2307/2853445
Google Scholar

Fine J.V.A. Jr., Letters-Lettres, “European Review of History” 2.2, 1995, p. 281, https://doi.org/10.1080/13507489508568142
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13507489508568142

Fine J.V.A. Jr., Mid-Fifteenth Century Sources on the Bosnian Church: their Problems and Significance, “Medievalia et humanistica” 12, 1984, p. 17–31.
Google Scholar

Fine J.V.A. Jr., Mysteries about the Newly Discovered Srebrenica-Visoko Bishopric in Bosnia (1434–1441), “East European Quarterly” 8, 1974, p. 29–43.
Google Scholar

Fine J.V.A. Jr., Novootkriveni izvor o prilikama u Bosni 1400. godine, “Godišnjak Društva istoričara Bosne i Hercegovine” 38, 1987, p. 107–109.
Google Scholar

Fine J.V.A. Jr., The Bosnian Church. Its Place in State and Society form the Thirteenth to the Fifteenth Centuries, London 2007.
Google Scholar

Fine J.V.A. Jr., The Bosnian Church: A New Interpretation. A Study of the Bosnian Church and its Place in State and Society form the 13th to the 15th Centuries, New York–London 1975.
Google Scholar

Fine J.V.A. Jr., The Early Medieval Balkans. A Critical Survey from the Sixth to the Late Twelfth Century, Ann Arbor 1983.
Google Scholar

Fine J.V.A. Jr., The Late Medieval Balkans. A Critical Survey from the Late Twelfth Century to the Ottoman Conquest, Ann Arbor 1987.
Google Scholar

Fine J.V.A. Jr., The Medieval and Ottoman Roots of Modern Bosnian Society, [in:] The Muslims of Bosnia – Herzegovina. Their Historic Development from the Middle Ages to the Dissolution of Yugoslavia, ed. M. Pinson, Cambridge 1994, p. 1–21.
Google Scholar

Fine J.V.A. Jr., Uloga bosanske crkve u javnom životu srednjovekovne Bosne, “Godišnjak Društva istoričara Bosne i Hercegovine” 19, 1970–1971, p. 19–29.
Google Scholar

Fine J.V.A. Jr., Was the Bosnian Banate Subjected to Hungary in the Second Half of the Thirteenth Century?, “East European Quarterly” 3, 1969, p. 167–177.
Google Scholar

Fine J.V.A. Jr., When Ethnicity did not Matter in the Balkans. A Study of Identity in Pre-Nationalist Croatia, Dalmatia, and Slavonia in Medieval and Early-Modern Periods, Ann Arbor 2006, https://doi.org/10.3998/mpub.17509
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.3998/mpub.17509

Fine J.V.A. Jr., Zaključci mojih posljednjih istraživanja o pitanju Bosanske crkve, [in:] Bogomislim in the Balkans in the Light of the Latest Research, ed. Lj. Lape, A. Benac, S. Ćirković, Skopje 1982, p. 127–133.
Google Scholar

Fine J.V.A. Jr., Donia R., Bosnia and Hercegovina. A Tradition Betrayed, London 1994.
Google Scholar

Hamilton B., The Albigensian Crusade and Heresy, [in:] The New Cambridge Medieval History,
Google Scholar

vol. V, ed. D. Abulafia, Cambridge 1999, p. 164–180, https://doi.org/10.1017/CHOL9780521362894.010
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CHOL9780521362894.010

Hamilton J., Hamilton B., Stoyanov Y., Christian Dualist Heresies in the Byzantine World, c. 650 – c. 1450, Manchester–New York 1998.
Google Scholar

Hoffman Berman C., Medieval Religion. New Approaches, New York–London 2005, https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203328675
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203328675

Horak J., [rec.:] The Bosnian Church, A New Interpretation: A Study of the Bosnian Church and its Place in State and Society from the 13th to the 15th Century. By John V. A. Fine, Jr. East European Monographs, no. 10. Boulder, Col.: East European Quarterly; New York and London: Columbia University Press, 1975. 447 pp. $17.50, “Journal of Church and State” 21, 1979, p. 583–584, https://doi.org/10.1093/jcs/21.3.583
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jcs/21.3.583

Janković B., Mijenjanje sebe same. Preobrazbe hrvatske historiografije kasnog socijalizma, Zagreb 2016.
Google Scholar

Koren S., Politika povijesti u Jugoslaviji (1945–1960), Zagreb 2012.
Google Scholar

Krekić B., Cirkulacija informacija između Dubrovnika i Bosne u prvoj polovini XV vijeka, “Godišnjak Društva istoričara Bosne i Hercegovine” 39, 1988, p. 50–56.
Google Scholar

Krekić B., Dva priloga bosanskoj istoriji prve polovine petnaestog vijeka, “Godišnjak Društva istoričara Bosne i Hercegovine” 37, 1986, p. 129–142.
Google Scholar

Krekić B., Mleci i unutrašnjost Balkana u četrnaestom veku, “Зборник Радова Византолошког Института” / “Zbornik radova Vizantološkog instituta” 21, 1982, p. 143–158.
Google Scholar

Krekić B., Prilog istoriji mletačko-balkanske trgovine druge polovine XIV veka, “Godišnjak Filozofskog fakulteta u Novom Sadu” 2, 1957, p. 11–19.
Google Scholar

Krekić B., [rec.:] The Bosnian Church: A New Interpretation. A Study of the Bosnian Church and its place in State and Society from the Thirteenth to the Fifteenth Centuries. By John V. A. Fine, Jr. East European Monographs, 10. Boulder, Colo.: East European Quaterly, 1975. x, 447 pp. $17.50. Dist. by Columbia University Press, New York, “Slavic Review” 36, 1977, p. 147–148, https://doi.org/10.2307/2494712
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/2494712

Logan F. D., A History of the Church in the Middle Ages, London–New York 2002.
Google Scholar

Lorenz M., Bogomilen, Katharer und bosnische “Christen”. Der Transfer dualistischer Häresien zwischen Orient und Okzident (11.–13. jh.), [in:] Vermitteln – Übersetzen – Begegnen. Transferphänomene im europäischen Mittelalter und in der Frühen Neuzeit. Interdisziplinäre Annäherungen, ed. B. J. Nemes, A. Rabus, Göttingen 2011, p. 87–136 [= Bogumili, katari i bosanski krstjani. Transfer dualističkih hereza između istoka i zapada (11–13. stoljeće), trans. N. Rabić, “Historijska traganja” 15, 2015, p. 9–66], https://doi.org/10.14220/9783847098409.87
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.14220/9783847098409.87

Lovrenović D., Stećci. Bosansko i humsko mramorje srednjeg vijeka, Zagreb 2013.
Google Scholar

Lovrenović D., Translatio sedis i uspostava novog konfesionalnog identiteta u srednjovjekovnoj Bosni – I, [in:] Franjevački samostan u Gučoj Gori, ed. V. Valjan, Guča Gora–Sarajevo 2010, p. 113–125.
Google Scholar

Lynch J. H., Adamo P. C., The Medieval Church. A Brief History, London–New York 2014, https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315735221
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315735221

Majeska G. P., [rec.:] John V. A. Fine, Jr. The Bosnian Church: A New Interpretation. A Study of the Bosnian Church and its Place in State and Society from the 13th to the 15th Centuries. (East European Monographs, number 10.) Boulder, Colo.: East European Quarterly; distributed by Columbia University Press, New York. 1975. Pp. ix, 447. $17.50., “American Historical Review” 82, 1977, p. 346–347, https://doi.org/10.1086/ahr/82.2.346-a
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/ahr/82.2.346-a

Markotić V., [rec.:] The Bosnian Church: A New Interpretation. JOHN V. A. FINE, Jr. Boulder, Col.: East European Quarterly, 1975. ix, 447 pp. $17.50. (Distributed by Columbia University Press), “Canadian Slavonic Papers” 20, 1978, p. 125–126, https://doi.org/10.1080/00085006.1978.11091517
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00085006.1978.11091517

Mojzes P., [rec.:] The Bosnian Church: A New Interpretation. By JOHN V.A. FINE, JR. Published by East European Quarterly. New York and London: Columbia University Press, 1975. 447 pp. $17.50., “Church History” 45, 1976, p. 251–252, https://doi.org/10.2307/3163726
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/3163726

Opširni popis Bosanskog sandžaka iz 1604. godine, vol. I–IV, Sarajevo 2000.
Google Scholar

Orbini M., Il regno degli Slavi hoggi corrottamente detti Schiavoni historia, Pesaro 1601.
Google Scholar

Petranović B., Bogomili. Crkva bosanska i krstjani. Istorička rasprava, Zadar 1867.
Google Scholar

Rački F., Bogomili i Patareni, “Rad Jugoslavenske Akademije Znanosti i Umjetnosti” 7, 1869, p. 86–179; “Rad Jugoslavenske Akademije Znanosti i Umjetnosti” 8, 1869, p. 121–187; “Rad Jugoslavenske Akademije Znanosti i Umjetnosti” 10, 1870, p. 160–263.
Google Scholar

Rački F., Bogomili i Patareni, Beograd 1931.
Google Scholar

Rački F., Bogomili i Patareni, Zagreb 1870.
Google Scholar

Rački F., Bogomili i Patareni, Zagreb 2003.
Google Scholar

Šanjek F., Les Chrétiens bosniaques et le movement cathare, XIIe–XVe siècles, Paris 1976.
Google Scholar

Šidak J., Današnje stanje pitanja ‘Crkve bosanske’ u historijskoj nauci, “Historijski Zbornik” 7, 1954, p. 129–142.
Google Scholar

Šidak J., Heretička “Crkva bosanska”, “Slovo” 27, 1977, p. 149–184.
Google Scholar

Šidak J., Pitanje ‘Crkve bosanske’ u novijoj literaturi, “Godišnjak Društva istoričara Bosne i Hercegovine” 5, 1953, p. 139–160.
Google Scholar

Šidak J., Problem ‘bosanske crkve’ u našoj historiografiji od Petranovića do Glušca (Prilog rješenju t. zv. Bogumilskog pitanja), “Rad Jugoslavenske Akademije Znanosti i Umjetnosti” 259, 1937, p. 37–182.
Google Scholar

Šidak J., Problem heretičke ‘Crkve bosanske’ u najnovijoj historiografiji (1962–75), “Historijski Zbornik” 27–28, 1974–1975, p. 139–182.
Google Scholar

Šidak J., Studije o “Crkvi bosanskoj” i bogumilstvu, Zagreb 1975.
Google Scholar

Simoniti V., [rec.:] John V. A. Fine, Jr., The Bosnian Church: A New Interpretation, A Study of the Bosnian Church and its Place in State and Society from the 13th to the 15th Centuries, East European Quaterly, Distributed by Columbia University Press, 1975 (kot 10. knjiga v zbirki East European Monographs), “Zgodovinski časopis” 33, 1979, p. 190–191.
Google Scholar

Stoyanov Y. P., The Other God. Dualist Religions from Antiquity to the Cathar Heresy, Yale 2000, https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctt5vm3q2
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctt5vm3q2

Wenzel M., Bosnian Style on Tombstones and Metal, Sarajevo 1999.
Google Scholar

Wiecyzinski J. L., [rec.:] The Bosnian Church: A New Interpretation. A Study of the Bosnian Church and its Place in State and Society from the 13th to the 15th Centuries. By John V. A. Fine, Jr. [East European Monographs, No. X.] (New York: Columbia University Press. 1975. Pp. ix, 449. $17.50), “The Catholic Historical Review” 64, 1978, p. 306–307.
Google Scholar

Wozniak F. E., [rec.:] John V. A. Fine Jr., The Bosnian Church: A New Interpretation, New York, Columbia University Press, 1975, 447 p., “Balkan Studies” 20, 1979, p. 185–187.
Google Scholar