On the Prehistory of Bogomilism – the Historical and Religious Continuum of the Dualistic Groups in Early Medieval Bulgaria (8th–10th Century)

Authors

  • Hristo Saldzhiev Trakia University – Stara Zagora, Faculty of Education, Department of Pedagogical and Social Sciences, St. Armejska 9, Stara Zagora 6000, Bulgaria; Plovdiv University – Paisii Hilendarski, Faculty of Philology, Department of History of Bulgarian Language and Common Linguistic https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4116-6600

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.18778/2084-140X.11.38

Keywords:

Bogomilism, Poto-Bogomilian group, Bulgaria, Manicheism, Masallianism, Marcionists, Paulicians

Abstract

The aim of the present article is to shed light on the prehistory of Bogomilism, in particular on the existence of an initial Proto-Bogomilian group from the second half of the 8th century to the first decades of the 10th century, which subsequently gave rise to Bogomilism. For this purpose I will try to regard problems referring to the time and exact place of its emergence, the cultural and ethnical affiliation of its first adherents, its connection with previous dualistic teachings from the Near East and Anatolia. The final conclusions are:

• The roots of Bogomilism must be sought among the Syriac migrants who settled in Thrace in the second half of the 8th century.

• Groups which shared a different kind of dualistic ideas and notions existed among them. The group that can be identified as “Proto-Bogomilian” most likely inhabited the region of Philippopolis/ Plovdiv and followed some branch of Paulicianism different from this of Paulicians who in the mid-9th century built the “Paulician state” in Tephrice.

• The dualism of the Proto-Bogomilian group stemmed from Marcion’s doctrine with some Manichean admixtures. It had experienced the influence of Masallianism long before the migration of this group towards the Balkans. This can explain the differences with Marcionists and Paulicians. The radical asceticism of the later Bogomils most probably must be attributed to the influence of Masallianism on the initial Proto-Bogomilian group too.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Anna Comnena, Alexias, [in:] Fontes graeci historiae bulgaricae, vol. VIII, ed. M. Vojnov et al., Sofia 1972, p. 7–149.
Google Scholar

Bethmann L.C., Die Evangelienhandschrift zu Cividale, Hannover 1877 [= Neues Archiv der Gesellschaft für ältere deutsche Geschichtskunde, 2].
Google Scholar

The Chronicle of Theophanes Confessor. Byzantine and Near Eastern History AD 284–813, trans. C. Mango, R. Scott, ass. G. Greatrex, Oxford 1997.
Google Scholar

Euthymius Zigabenus, De haeresi Bogomilorum narratio, [in:] Fontes graeci historiae bulgaricae, vol. X, ed. G. Cankova-Petrova, P. Koledarov, Sofia 1972, p. 50–75.
Google Scholar

Joan Ekzarh, šestodnev, trans. N. Kochev, Sofija 1981.
Google Scholar

Josephus Flavius, Complete Works. Antiques of the Jews, vol. I, trans. S. Havercamp, New York 1900.
Google Scholar

Petri Siculi Historia Manichaeorum seu Paulicianorum, Gottingae 1846.
Google Scholar

Popruženko M., Sinodik carja Borila, Sofija 1928.
Google Scholar

Prezviter′′ Kozma, Beseda protiv bogomilitě, trans. V. Kiselkov, Sofija 1939.
Google Scholar

Rainer Sacconi, Summa fratris Raynerii de ordine fratrum praedicatorum, de Catharis et Pauperibus de Lugduno, [in:] Fontes latini historiae bulgaricae, vol. IV, ed. M. Vojnov et al., Sofia 1981, p. 159–178.
Google Scholar

Theophanes Confessor, Chronographia, [in:] Fontes graeci historiae bulgaricae, vol. III, ed. I. Dujčev et al., Sofia 1960, p. 226–289.
Google Scholar

Theophylacti Constantinopolis patriarchae epistola Petro Bulgarorum regi, [in:] Fontes graeci historiae bulgaricae, vol. V, ed. V. Tapkova-Zaimova, Sofıa 1964, p. 183–189.
Google Scholar

Theophylactus Achridensis, Archiepiscopus Bulgariae, Bios kai politeia, omologia te kai meriki thaumatōn diigisis tou en agiois patros imōn Klimentos episkopou Boulgarōn, synnrafeisa para tou agiōtatou kai aoidimou archiepiskopou tis prōtis Ioustinianis kai pasis Boulgarias, kyrou Theofylaktou, chrimatisantos en Kōnstantinoupolei maistoros ton ritorōn, [in:] Fontes graeci historiae bulgaricae, vol. IX.2, ed., trans. I. Iliev, Sofia 1994, p. 10–41.
Google Scholar

Angelov D., Bogomilstvoto, Sofija 1993.
Google Scholar

Beševliev V., Părvobălgarski nadpisi, Sofija 1992.
Google Scholar

Bolotov V., Lekcii po istorii Drevnej Cerkvi, vol. II, Istorija cerkvi v period do Konstantina Velikogo, Moskva 1994.
Google Scholar

Borisov B., Arheologičeskie svidetel′stva prabolgarskogo prisustvija na territorii Južnoj Bolgarii, “Поволжская археология” / “Povolžskaja arheologija” 2, 2012, p. 50–65 http://archaeologie.pro/en/archive/2/23/
Google Scholar

Box G., Landsman J., The Apocalypse of Abraham, London–New York 1919.
Google Scholar

Bozóky E., Le livre secret des cathares: Interrogatio Iohannis. Apocryphe d’origine bogomile, Paris 1980.
Google Scholar

Brockelmann C., Lexicon Syriacum, Halle 1928.
Google Scholar

Chalyan-Dafner K., Natural Disasters in Mamlūk Egypt (1250–1517). Perceptions, Interpretations and Human Responses, Heidelberg 2013 (unpublished PhD dissertation) http://archiv.ub.uniheidelberg.de/volltextserver/17711/1/Chalyan-Daffner.pdf [18 XII 2019].
Google Scholar

Cibranska-Kostova M., Katarskijat trebnik i bogomilskata knižnina, “Palaeobulgarica / Старобъ-лгаристика” 26, 2004, p. 42–67.
Google Scholar

Cirkin Ju., Mify Finikii i Ugarita, Moskva 2003.
Google Scholar

Dančeva-Vasileva A., Plovdiv prez srednovekovieto (IV–XIV vek), Sofija 2011.
Google Scholar

Dragojlović D., Bogomilstvo na Balkanu i u Maloj Aziji, Beograd 1974.
Google Scholar

Drakopoulos T., L’unité du bogomilo-catharisme. D’après quatre textes latins analysés à la lumière des sources byzantines, Genève 2010 (disertation).
Google Scholar

Dujčev I., Rilskijat svetec i negovata obitel, Sofija 1990.
Google Scholar

Eliade M., Istorija na religioznite vjarvanija i idei, vol. I, Ot kamennija vek do Elevsinskite misterii, trans. T. Mineva, Sofija 1997.
Google Scholar

Evans A., The Development of Jewish Ideas of Angels. Egyptian and Hellenistic Connections ca. 600 BCE to ca. 200 CE, Stellenbosch 2007 (unpublished PhD dissertation) https://scholar.sun.ac.za/handle/10019.1/1398 [29 VI 2021].
Google Scholar

Gagova K., Trakija prez bălgarskoto srednovekovie, Sofija 2002.
Google Scholar

Grozdanova G., Naselenieto na Južna Bălgarija VI–IX v. (Po arheologičeski danni), Sofija 2018.
Google Scholar

Ivanov I., Minkova M., Ošte vednăž za srednovekovnite kamenni relefi ot Stara Zagora, “Известия на Старозагорския исторически музей” / “Izvestija na Starozagorskija Istoričeski Muzej” 3, 2008, p. 177–184.
Google Scholar

Ivanov J., Bălgarski starini iz Makedonija, Sofija 1970.
Google Scholar

Ivanov J., Bogomilski knigi i legendi, Sofija 1970.
Google Scholar

Janev B., Sistema na ličnite imena v bălgarskija i nemskija ezik, Plovdiv 2009.
Google Scholar

Keith-Falconer I.G.N., Kalīlah and Dimnah or the Fables of Bidpai, Cambridge 1885.
Google Scholar

Kleczkowska K., Comparative Analysis of the Motif of the Reed in the Mesopotamian Myth of the Flood and the Greek Myth of King Midas, “Ex Nihilo” 8, 2012, p. 93–109.
Google Scholar

Konstantinova V., Njakoi beležki za protivobogomilskija nadpis ot Eskus, “Археология” / “Arheologija” 3–4, 1982, p. 50–55.
Google Scholar

Kožuharov S., Problemi na starobălgarskata poezija, Sofija 2004.
Google Scholar

Loos M., Dualist Heresy in the Middle Ages, Prague 1974.
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-015-1212-1

Lourié B., Direct Translations into Slavonic from Syriac: a Preliminary List, [in:] ΠΟΛΥΙΣΤΩΡ. Scripta Slavica. Mario Capaldo Dicata, ed. C. Diddi, Moscow–Rome 2015, p. 161–169.
Google Scholar

Milev A., Grăckite žitiya na Kliment Ohridski, Sofija 1966.
Google Scholar

Miltenov Ja., Apokrifnijat apokalipsis na Joan Bogoslov – analiz na meždutekstovite otnošenija, “Palaeobulgarica / Старобългаристика” 27, 2004, p. 85–102.
Google Scholar

Muraoka T., Classical Syriac. A Basic Grammar with a Chrestomathy, Wiesbaden 2005.
Google Scholar

Murav′ev A., Mar Ischak Ninevijskij. Kniga o voschoždenii inoka. Pervoe sobranie (traktaty I–VI), Moskva 2016.
Google Scholar

Mustafova A., Relikti na dualizma v Suprasălskija sbornik. Avtoreferat na disertatsija, Šumen 2015.
Google Scholar

Nişanyan S., Sözlük. Çağdaş Türkçenin Etimolojisi https://www.nisanyansozluk.com/?k=baba&lnk=1 [21 III 2021].
Google Scholar

Orenburg M., Gnostičeskij mif. Rekonstrukcija i interpretacija, Moskva 2013.
Google Scholar

Ovčarov D., Hudožestvenata keramika v bălgarskite zemi, Sofija 2010.
Google Scholar

Panajotov V., Za edin ranen plast v službata na sveti Joan Rilski po prepisa ot 1451 godina, [in:] Glǫbiny kъnižnyję, vol. IV, ed. V. Panayotov, Šumen 2006, p. 218–227.
Google Scholar

Panayotov V., An Acrostic with the Name of Priest Bogomil, “Studia Hungaro-Bulgarica” 3, 2014, p. 141–148.
Google Scholar

Payne Smith J., A Compendious Syriac Dictionary, Oxford 1903.
Google Scholar

Payne Smith R., Thesaurus Syriacus, Oxonii 1879.
Google Scholar

Petkanova D., Starobălgarska literatura IX–XVIII vek, Sofija 1992.
Google Scholar

Philo of Byblos, The Phoenician History, trans. et praef. H. Attridge, R. Oden, Washington 1981 [= The Catholic Biblical Quarterly. Monograph Series, 9].
Google Scholar

Popkonstantinov K., Runičeski nadpisi ot srednovekovna Bălgarija, [in:] Studia protobulgarica et mediaevalia europensia. V čest na profesor Veselin Beševliev, ed. V. Gjuzelev, K. Popkonstantinov, Veliko Tărnovo 1993, p. 141–162.
Google Scholar

Popkonstantinov K., Zaklinatelni molitvi vărhu olovni amuleti ot srednovekovna Bălgarija i paralelite im v Trebnici ot srednovekovna Sărbija, “Зборник радова Византолошког института” / “Zbornik radova Vizantološkog instituta” 46, 2009, p. 341–350.
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.2298/ZRVI0946341P

Rabovjanov D., Izvănstoličnite kamenni kreposti na Părvoto bălgarsko carstvo, Sofija 2011.
Google Scholar

Soloviev A., Autour des Bogomilies, “Byzantion” 22, 1952, p. 81–104.
Google Scholar

Stančev K., Tvorčestvoto na Sv. Kliment Ohridski v naučnite izsledvanija i izdanija prez poslednite 30 godini (1986–2016), [in:] Sv. Kliment Ohridski v kulturata na Evropa, ed. S. Kujumžieva, Sofija 2018, p. 30–52.
Google Scholar

Stanev K., Sliven – administrativen centăr na oblastta Zagora prez IX–X vek, [in:] Bălgarija v svetovnoto kulturno nasledstvo, Šumen 2014, p. 542–550.
Google Scholar

Stanev K., Trakija prez rannoto srednovekovie, Veliko Tărnovo 2012.
Google Scholar

Stefanov P., Jaldavaot. Istorija i učenie na gnostičeskata religija, Sofija 2008.
Google Scholar

Tardio M., Manihejstvoto, trans. M. Jončev, Sofija 2001.
Google Scholar

Topalov I., Stanev K., Two Bulgar Pagan Burials from Plovdiv, [in:] Avars, Bulgars and Magyars on the Middle and Lower Danube, ed. L. Doncheva-Petkova, C. Balogh, A. Türk, Sofia–Budapest 2014, p. 83–89.
Google Scholar

Turaev B., Šifman I., Finikijskaja mifologija, Sankt-Peterburg 1999.
Google Scholar

Tyson J., Marcion and Luke-Acts. A Defining Struggle, Columbia 2006.
Google Scholar

Vакlinov S., Formirane na starobălgarskata kultura VI–XI vek, Sofija 1977.
Google Scholar

Wolski J., Autoproscoptae, Bogomils and Messalians in the 14th Century Bulgaria, “Studia Ceranea” 4, 2014, p. 233–241 https://doi.org/10.18778/2084-140X.04.15
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.18778/2084-140X.04.15

Zaimov Y., Nov starobălgarski pametnik. Părvomajski nadpis ot XI–XII v., “Български език” / “Bălgarski ezik” 4, 1983, p. 290–295.
Google Scholar

Downloads

Published

2021-12-30

How to Cite

Saldzhiev, H. (2021). On the Prehistory of Bogomilism – the Historical and Religious Continuum of the Dualistic Groups in Early Medieval Bulgaria (8th–10th Century). Studia Ceranea. Journal of the Waldemar Ceran Research Centre for the History and Culture of the Mediterranean Area and South-East Europe, 11, 721–761. https://doi.org/10.18778/2084-140X.11.38

Issue

Section

Articles