On (Quasi-)Gnostic Strategies for Overcoming Cognitive Dissonance. The Bulgarian Case
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18778/2084-140X.09.05Keywords:
Gnosis, Orthodox Christianity, anti-Semitism, Bulgarian culture, cultural transferAbstract
The article poses a research question, important not only in the studies on (neo-)gnosticism, concerning the relationship between the gnostic strategies of interpreting the world (and especially its typical rules of classifying people, based on the externalization of evil) and the tendency to construct a figure of “hylic” as a person embodying evil, and thus “unworthy of life”. In this context, the author is interested in the dynamics of the relationship between the religious worldview declared by the authors, the one they actually profess, and their attitude towards the so-called Jewish question. Bulgarian material, which is a case of a particular kind of aporia, cognitive dissonances emerging due to tension between the pressure of cultural stereotypes, pragmatic (economic), religious, parareligious and humanistic thinking, has been analyzed on the basis of post-secular thought. The investigator posits that Bulgarian culture, despite the “economic” anti-Semitism that exists within it, did not produce a figure of a Jew the hylic that absorbs all evil and that could be inscribed (as is the case in popular Polish culture, among others) in every troublesome local political and symbolic context.
Downloads
References
Avramov R., “Spasenie” i padenie. Mikroikonomika na dăržavnija antisemitizăm v Bălgarija 1940–1944 g., Sofija 2012.
Google Scholar
Cohen L., Ti vjarvaš. Osem pogleda vărhu Holokosta na Balkanite, Sofija 2012.
Google Scholar
Deportiraneto na evreite ot Vardarska Makedonija, Belomorska Trakija i Pirot, Mart 1943 g., vol. I–II, ed. N. Danova, R. Avramov, Sofija 2013.
Google Scholar
Evreite po bălgarskite zemi. Anotirana bibliografija, ed. Ž. Eskenazi, A. Krispin, Sofija 2002.
Google Scholar
Genov R., Dizraeli, evrejstvoto i antisemitizmăt v Bălgarija, http://dialogueeurope.org/uploads/JewsCol/Panel101.pdf [12 IX 2018].
Google Scholar
Gezenko I., Zakonodatelnata i izpălnitelnata vlast v izgraždaneto na antievrejskoto zakonodatelstvo 1940–1944 г…, [in:] Obrečeni i spaseni. Bălgarija v antisemitskata programa na Tretija rajh. Izsledvanija i dokumenti, Sofija 2007.
Google Scholar
Hristov K., Ot nacija kăm rasa, “Училищен преглед” / “Učilišten pregled” 8, 1929.
Google Scholar
Ilčev I., Mităt za San Stefanska Bălgarija kato “sveštena krava” na bălgarskija nacionalizăm, http://www.segabg.com/online/new/articlenew.asp?issueid=1486§ionid=8&id=00003/ [22 I 2019].
Google Scholar
Kalkandjieva D., The Bulgarian Orthodox Church’s Contribution to the Rescue of Jews in Bulgaria during WWII: A Model of Religious Tolerance & Social Solidarity, https://www.academia.edu/2184932/The_Bulgarian_Orthodox_Churchs_Contribution_to_the_Rescue_of_Jews_in_Bulgaria_during_WWII_A_Model_of_Religious_Tolerance_and_Social_Solidarity [10 IX 2018].
Google Scholar
Karavelov L., Zapiski za Bălgarija i bălgarite, Sofija 1930.
Google Scholar
Krăsteva Z., Pravni aspekti na dăržavnata antievrejska politika v Carstvo Bălgarija (1940–1944 g.), Berlin.
Google Scholar
Nedeleva P., Antievrejskoto zakonodatelstvo v Bălgarija prez Vtorata svetovna vojna, Sofija 2013.
Google Scholar
Nedeleva P., Mjasto i rolja na evrejskata obštnost v bălgarskite zemi (ot osmansko vladičestvo do 30-te godini na XX v.), “Юридическо списание на НБУ” / “Juridičesko spisanie na NBU” 2, 2013, p. 33–58.
Google Scholar
Oceljavaneto 1940–1944 (The Survival 1940–1944), ed. D. Cohen, Sofija 1995.
Google Scholar
P., S vjara v Bog se pobeždava svetovnoto zlo, “Църковен вестник” / “Cărkoven vestnik” 48, 1941, p. 1–2.
Google Scholar
The Power of Civil Society in a Time of Genocide. Proceedings of the Holy Synod of the Bulgarian Orthodo XChurch on the Rescue of the Jews in Bulgaria 1940–1944, Sofia 2005.
Google Scholar
Rajčevski S., Bălgari i evrei prez vekovete, Sofija 2008.
Google Scholar
Tokušev D., Antievrejskoto zakonodatelstvo i negovoto preodoljavane (1942–1945 g.), Sofija 2010.
Google Scholar
Vazov I., Kăm propast, http://www.slovo.bg/showwork.php3?AuID=14&WorkID=8693&Level=1 [16 I 2019].
Google Scholar
Vazov I., Svetoslav Terter. Ivan Aleksandăr, Sofija 1980.
Google Scholar
Vazov I., Tăgite na Bălgarija, Bukurešt 1877.
Google Scholar
Zakon za zaštita na nacijata, DV, No 16 ot 23.01.1941 g.
Google Scholar
Arendt H., Eichmann in Jerusalem. A Report on the Banality of Evil, London 2006.
Google Scholar
Benjamin W., On the Concept of History, New York 2009.
Google Scholar
Brumlik M., Gnostycy. Marzenie o samozbawieniu człowieka, trans. Ś.F. Nowicki, I. Nowicka, Gdańsk 1999.
Google Scholar
Brykczyński P., Gotowi na przemoc. Mord, antysemityzm i demokracja w międzywojennej Polsce, Warszawa 2017.
Google Scholar
Dąbek-Wirgowa T., O antynomii swoi – obcy z perspektywy bułgarskiej, [in:] Kategorie peryferii i centrum w kształtowaniu się kultur narodowych, ed. T. Dąbek-Wirgowa, J. Wierzbicki, Warszawa 1986.
Google Scholar
Drzewiecka E., Herezja Judasza w kulturze (ponowoczesnej). Studium przypadku, Kraków 2016.
Google Scholar
Dupré L., The Other Dimension. A Search for the Meaning of Religious Attitudes, Garden City 1972.
Google Scholar
The Experience of Faith in Slavic Cultures and Literatures in the Context of Postsecular Thought, ed. E. Drzewiecka, D. Sosnowska, Warszawa 2018.
Google Scholar
Festinger L., A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance, Stanford 1957.
Google Scholar
Fleck L., Powstanie i rozwoj faktu naukowego, Warszawa 1986.
Google Scholar
Ginzburg C., Il formaggio e i vermi, Torino 1976.
Google Scholar
Israel J., Radical Enlightenment. Philosophy and the Making of Modernity 1650–1750, Oxford 2002.
Google Scholar
Kuhn T., The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, Chicago 1962.
Google Scholar
Ogonowski Z., Socynianizm. Dzieje, poglądy, oddziaływanie, Warszawa 2015.
Google Scholar
Quispel G., Gnoza, Warszawa 1988.
Google Scholar
Ricoeur P., The Symbolism of Evil, trans. E. Buchanan, Boston 1969.
Google Scholar
Rusin B., Ekscesy antyżydowskie na ziemiach bułgarskich Imperium Osmańskiego w czasie wojny rosyjsko-tureckiej 1877–1878, http://apcz.umk.pl/czasopisma/index.php/SDR/article/view/SDR.2016.1.01 [10 IX 2018].
Google Scholar
Scatolla M., Teologia politica, Bologna 2007.
Google Scholar
Skarga B., O znaczeniu wymiaru metafizycznego w kulturze, [in:] Człowiek to nie jest piękne zwierzę, Kraków 2007, p. 10–25.
Google Scholar
Szwat-Gyłybowa G., Haeresis bulgarica w bułgarskiej świadomości kulturowej XIX i XX wieku, Warszawa 2005.
Google Scholar
Szwat-Gyłybowa G., Playing Catch up: The Notion of Needing to Accelerate a Country’s Progress Towards a Civilised Paradise – The Bulgarian Version, “Slavia Meridionalis” 14, 2014, p. 310–328.
Google Scholar
Tamir V., Bulgaria and Her Jews. The History of a Dubious Symbiosis, New York 1979.
Google Scholar
Taubes J., Apokalipsa i polityka. Eseje mesjańskie, Warszawa 2013.
Google Scholar
Todorova O., Evreite v bălgarskata slovesnost ot načaloto na XIX vek do Osvoboždenieto, http://www.librev.com/index.php/discussion-bulgaria-publisher/1759--ix- [12 IX 2018].
Google Scholar
Todorova O., The Nineteenth-Century Bulgarians’ Perception of the Jews, “Études balkaniques” 1995.3/4, p. 40–41.
Google Scholar
Todorova O., Obrazăt na “nečestivija evrein” bălgarskata knižnina ot ХVІІІ – načaloto na XIX vek i văv folklora, “Byzantinische Forschungen. Internationale Zeitschrift für Byzantinistik” 3, 1994, p. 10–21.
Google Scholar
Todorova O., Mirčeva K., Familijata Milingen i bălgarite prez tretata četvărt na ХIХ vek, https://www.marginalia.bg/aktsent/familiyata-milingen-i-balgarite-prez-tretata-chetvart-nahih-vek/ [12 III 2018].
Google Scholar
Tokarska-Bakir J., Legendy o krwi. Antropologia przesądu, Warszawa 2008.
Google Scholar
Tokarska-Bakir J., Pod klątwą. Społeczny portret pogromu kieleckiego, Warszawa 2018.
Google Scholar
Voegelin E., Od oświecenia do rewolucji, Warszawa 2011.
Google Scholar
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
