The Economy as Instituted Process. Karl Polanyi’s Institutionalism and Its Ethical Consequences
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18778/1899-2226.20.2.04Keywords:
Karl Polanyi, Douglass North, institutionalism, ethicsAbstract
This article is devoted to a critical reconstruction of Karl Polanyi’s institutional theory and its ethical consequences. Starting with the distinction between the formal (neoclassical) and the substantial (institutional) understanding of the economy, the article proceeds to discuss the main forms of institutional integration of economic life described by Polanyi: reciprocity (symmetry), redistribution (centricity), and exchange (market). In this context, the author examines the connection between the work of Karl Polanyi and the economic anthropology represented by the works of Richard Thurnwald and Bronisław Malinowski. The author argues that three main forms of institutional integration of economic life introduced by Karl Polanyi can be interpreted both as analytical tools to describe institutions and as a grand scheme for the classification of different economic systems. The next section of the article is devoted to a comparison between the institutional theories of Douglass North and Karl Polanyi. For North, the main explanatory category is the idea of transaction costs, whereas for Polanyi the key idea is that of the social embeddedness of the economy. When speaking about the social embeddedness of the economy, Polanyi draws our attention to the inseparable bonds which exist between economic institu tions on the one hand, and culture, social structure and politics on the other hand. This theoretical difference between North and Polanyi, the author argues, has important ethical consequences. If Polanyi is right, then institutions are not only alternative solutions to a certain economic problem (i.e. the efficient allocation of resources, the reduction of transaction costs) but above all they are the embodiment of different conceptions of a good life. In conclusion, the author emphasizes the political dimension of Karl Polanyi’s institutional theory with its intriguing promise of liberating our social and political life from the economic fallacy, that is, from the unfortunate tendency to think about society in market terms.
References
Becker G.S., Ekonomiczna teoria zachowań ludzkich, PWN, Warszawa 1990.
Google Scholar
Blyth M., Structures Do Not Come with an Instruction Sheet: Interests, Ideas, and Progress in Political Science, „Perspectives on Politics” 2003, vol. 1, nr 4.
Google Scholar
Blyth M., The Great Transformations. Economic Ideas and Institutional Change in the Twentieth Century, Cambridge 2002.
Google Scholar
Cangiani M., Karl Polanyi’s Institutional Theory: Market Society and It’s Disembedded Economy, „Journal of Economic Issues” 2011, vol. 45, nr 1.
Google Scholar
Chang H., Ekonomia. Instrukcja obsługi, Wydawnictwo Krytyki Politycznej, Warszawa 2015.
Google Scholar
Dale G., Karl Polanyi. The Limits of the Market, Polity Press, Cambridge and Malden 2010.
Google Scholar
Denzau A., D. North, Shared Mental Models: Ideologies and Institutions, „Kyklos” 1994, vol. 47.
Google Scholar
Gemici, K., Karl Polanyi and the Antinomies of Embeddedness, „Socio-Economic Review” 2008, vol. 6, nr 1.
Google Scholar
Hann Ch., K. Hart, Economic Anthropology. History, Ethnography, Critique, Polity Press, Cambridge and Malden 2011.
Google Scholar
Kapp, K.W., Social Economics and Social Welfare Minima [w:] Towards a Sociology of Culture in India. Essays in Honor of Dr. D. P. Mukerji, red. T.K.N. Unnithan et al. Prentice Hall of India, New Delhi 1965.
Google Scholar
Kostello E., I. Szelényi, Outline of an Institutionalist Theory of Inequality: The Case of Socialist and Postcommunist Eastern Europe [w:] The New Institutionalism in Sociology, red. M. Brinton, V. Nee, Russell Sage Foundation, New York 1998.
Google Scholar
Malinowski B., Zwyczaj i zbrodnia w społeczności dzikich [w:] idem, Dzieła, t. II, Warszawa 1980.
Google Scholar
Maucourant J., S. Plociniczak, The Institution, the Economy, and the Market: Karl Polanyi’s Institutional Thought for Economists, „Review of Political Economy” 2013, vol. 25, nr 3.
Google Scholar
Market and Society. The Great Transformation Today, red. Ch. Hann, K. Hart, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2011.
Google Scholar
North D., Economic Performance Through Time [w:] The New Institutionalism in Sociology, red. M. Brinton, V. Nee, Russell Sage Foundation, New York 1998.
Google Scholar
North D., Markets and Other Allocation Systems in History. The Challenge of Karl Polanyi, „Journal of European Economic History” 1977, vol. 6, nr 3.
Google Scholar
North D., Review of The Livelihood of Man by Karl Polanyi, „Business History Reviews” 1978, vol. 52, nr 3.
Google Scholar
Polanyi K., Aristotle Discovers Economy [w:] Trade and Market in Early Empires. Economies in History and Theory, red. K. Polanyi, C.M. Arensberg, H.W. Pearson, The Free Press, Glencoe, Illinois 1957.
Google Scholar
Polanyi K., Carl Menger’s Two Meanings of „Economic” [w:] Studies in Economic Anthropology, red. G. Dalton, Washington 1971.
Google Scholar
Polanyi K., Dahomey and The Slave Trade. An Analysis of an Archaic Economy, University of Washington Press, Seattle and London 1966.
Google Scholar
Polanyi K., For a New West, Polity Press, Malden and Cambridge 2014.
Google Scholar
Polanyi K., Livelihood of Man, red. H.W. Pearson, Academic Press, New York, San Francisco, London 1977.
Google Scholar
Polanyi K., The Economy as Instituted Process [w:] Trade and Market in Early Empires. Economies in History and Theory, red. K. Polanyi, C.M. Arensberg, H.W. Pearson, The Free Press, Glencoe, Illinois 1957.
Google Scholar
Polanyi K., Wielka transformacja. Polityczne i ekonomiczne źródła naszych czasów, tłum. M. Zawadzka, Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN, Warszawa 2010.
Google Scholar
Reading Karl Polanyi for Twenty-First Century: Market Economy as a Political Project, red. A. Burga, K. Agartan, Palgrave Macmillan, New York 2007.
Google Scholar
Robbins L., An Essay on The Nature and Significance of Economic Science, Macmillan, London 1932.
Google Scholar
Schaniel W.C., W.C. Neale, Karl Polanyi’s Forms of Integration as Ways of Mapping, „Journal of Economic Issues” 2000, vol. 34, nr 1.
Google Scholar
Stanfield J.R., The Economic Thought of Karl Polanyi: Lives and Livelihoods, Palgrave, Macmillan, New York 1986.
Google Scholar
Streeck W., P. Schmitter, Community, Market, State – and Associations? The Prospective Contribution of Interest Governance to Social Order, „European Sociological Review” 1985, vol. 1, nr 2.
Google Scholar
Streeck W., Re-forming Capitalism. Institutional Change in the German Political Economy, Oxford University Press 2009.
Google Scholar
Szelényi I., Karl Polanyi and the Theory of a Socialist Mixed Economy [w:] The Legacy of Karl Polanyi. Market, State and Society at the End of Twentieth Century, red. M. Mendell, D. Salée, St. Martin Press, New York 1991.
Google Scholar
Thurnwald R., Bánaro Society. Social Organization and Kinship System of a Tribe in the Interior of New Guinea, Memories of the American Anthropological Association, vol. III, nr 4, 1916.
Google Scholar
