“Same Old Ed, . . . Uncommitted”: BMW Socialism and Post-Roguery in Guy Vanderhaeghe’s Early Fiction
Keywords:Guy Vanderhaeghe, Saskatchewan, socialism, Slavoj Žižek, postmodernism
In this paper I assess how Guy Vanderhaeghe’s early fiction criticizes the class-based and civil movements of post-1960s Saskatchewan through the recurring character of Ed. The protagonist of “Man Descending” and “Sam, Soren, and Ed” from Man Descending, the uncollected “He Scores! He Shoots!” and the novel My Present Age, Ed both condemns and epitomizes the contaminated and seductive gestures of the movements’ influences and enterprises. Vanderhaeghe deploys layers of social criticism: the first comments on the new urban progressive generation—the BMW socialists—while another manifests a counter-criticism that comments on those who challenge social progress, questioning their motives and the credibility of their critique. But what is a BMW socialist? A sociopolitical chameleon hiding behind pretense? Ed describes such a creature as a former “nay-sayer and boycotter” who “intended to dedicate his life to eternal servitude in a legal-aid clinic,” but then “affluence did him in” and now “his ass [is] cupped lovingly in the contoured leather seats of his BMW” (Man Descending 237–38). Vanderhaeghe’s early works criticize the contemporary middle class and progressivist movements of the second half of the twentieth century through this sociopolitical rogue—who in turn becomes a post-rogue. For Ed is ironically undercut by a counter-narrative that is often sub-textual, resulting in a fascinating appraisal of social ignorance, immobility, and unproductivity rather than of any specific ideology.
Avakumovic, Ivan. Socialism in Canada: A Study of the CCF-NDP in Federal and Provincial Politics. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1987. Print.
Brown, Lorne A., Joseph K. Roberts, and John W. Warnock. Saskatchewan Politics from Left to Right ’44–’99. Regina: Hinterland, 1999. Print.
Dunning, Stephen. “What Would Sam Waters Do? Guy Vanderhaeghe and Søren Kierkegaard.” Canadian Literature 198 (2008): 29–45. Print.
Eagles, Munroe. “Political Geography and the Study of Regionalism.” Regionalism and Party Politics in Canada. Ed. Lisa Young and Keith Archer. Toronto: Oxford UP, 2001. 9–23. Print.
Endres, Robin. “Marxist Literary Criticism and English Canadian Literature.” In Our Own House: Social Perspectives on Canadian Literature. Ed. Paul Cappon. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1978. 82–129. Print.
Faieta, Nicola A. “‘Guy Talk’: An Interview with Guy Vanderhaeghe.” SCL 35.1 (2010): 256–72. Print.
Fairbairn, Brett. “Canada’s ‘Co-Operative Province’: Individualism and Mutualism in a Settler Society.” Perspectives of Saskatchewan. Ed. Jene M. Porter. Winnipeg: U of Manitoba P, 2009. 149–74. Print.
Forceville, Charles. “My Present Age and the ‘Ed’-stories: The Role of Language and Story-Telling in Guy Vanderhaeghe’s Fiction.” External and Detached: Dutch Essays on Contemporary Canadian Literature. Ed. Charles Forceville. Amsterdam: Free UP, 1988. 53–61. Print.
Friesen, Gerald. The Canadian Prairies: A History. Toronto: U of Toronto P, 1987. Print.
Grant, C. J. “The March of Roguery.” Commons.wikimedia.org. Wikimedia Commons, public domain. Web. 17 Jun. 2017.
Griswold, Wendy. Regionalism and the Reading Class. Chicago: U of Chicago P, 2008. Print.
Hillis, Doris. Voices & Visions: Interviews with Saskatchewan Writers. Moose Jaw: Coteau, 1985. Print.
Horava, Tony. “Guy Vanderhaeghe: A Bibliography.” Essays on Canadian Writing 58 (1996): 241–65. Print.
Kruk, Laurie. “Storykeepers: Circling Family Voice in Stories by Thomas King, Olive Senior, Alistair Macleod and Guy Vanderhaeghe.” Journal of the Short Story in English 47 (2006): 1–13. Print.
Mathews, Robin. “Developing a Language of Struggle: Canadian Literature and Literary Criticism.” In Our Own House: Social Perspectives on Canadian Literature. Ed. Paul Cappon. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1978. 135–47. Print.
Owram, Doug. “Uncertain Promise: The Prairie Farmer and the Post-War Era.” The Prairie West as Promised Land. Ed. R. Douglas Francis and Chris Kitzan. Calgary: U of Calgary P, 2007. 335–55. Print.
Penner, Norman. From Protest to Power: Social Democracy in Canada 1900–Present. Toronto: J. Lorimer, 1992. Print.
Smith, David E. “Saskatchewan: A Distinct Political Culture.” Perspectives of Saskatchewan. Ed. Jene M. Porter. Winnipeg: U of Manitoba P, 2009. 37–56. Print.
The Waffle Manifesto. Canadian League of Rights 1974 (1969). Socialisthistory.ca. Web. 17 Jun. 2017.
Vanderhaeghe, Guy. “He Scores! He Shoots!” Matrix 13 (1981): 3–14. Print.
Vanderhaeghe, Guy. Man Descending. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 2000 (1982). Print.
Vanderhaeghe, Guy. My Present Age. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 2000 (1984). Print.
Vanderhaeghe, Guy. “Sam, Soren, and Ed.” Journal of Canadian Fiction 31–32 (1981): 5–31. Print.
Williams, Raymond. Marxism and Literature. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1977. Print.
Zichy, Francis. “Guy Vanderhaeghe’s Notes Towards the ‘Big Book’ of His Generation: Man Descending in the Sociopolitical Context of the 1960s and 1970s.” American Review of Canadian Studies 48.1 (2018): 41–62. Print.
Žižek, Slavoj. “The Interpassive Subject.” Lacan.com. Lacan Dot Com 2009. Web. 21 Mar. 2017.