The First Woman Yamī, Her Origin and Her Status in Indo-Iranian Mythology: Demigoddess or Half-human? (Evidence from R̥gveda 10.10, Iranian Parallels and Greek Relatives)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18778/2084-140X.08.03Keywords:
Yamī, Yama, Indo-Iranian mythology, RgvedaAbstract
This paper focuses on the mythology of Yamī and her twin-brother Yama (the first humans according to Indo-Iranian mythology), their non-human origin and some aspects of Yamī’s behaviour which presumably betray a number of features of a female half-deity. The relationships between Yamī and Yama are the central topic of the dialogue hymn Rgveda 10.10, where Yamī attempts to seduce her twin to incest in order to produce offspring and thus continue the human race. This offer is refused by Yama, who refers to the inappropriateness of incest. Although Yamī and Yama are humans according to the Vedic tradition, their origin from two half-deities – a Gandharva father and an Apsara mother – remains inexplicable: how could a couple of non-human beings (half-deities or demons) give birth to humans? Obviously, the mythological status of the twins should be reconsidered. I argue that at least one of them, Yamī, retains immortality and some other features of the non-human (semi-divine) nature. On the basis of the analysis of the Yama and Yamī hymn and some related Vedic texts, I argue that this assumption may account for certain peculiarities of Yamī’s behaviour – particularly her hypersexuality (which can be qualified as demonic type of behaviour), as opposed to the much more constrained, human type of conduct displayed by Yama. Given the notoriously lustful character of the Gandharvas, an origin from this semi-divine creature may account for Yamī’s hypersexuality. Although the word gandharvá- does not have Indo-European etymology, we can find possible Indo-European parallels. In particular, the Gandharvas are comparable with the Centaurs, which cannot be etymologically related but possibly originate in the same non-Indo-European source. There are some reasons to assume that both words are borrowed from the Kassite language and mythology, which, in turn, may have been related to the language and culture of the Proto-North-Caucasians. Although we do not find exact equivalents of Yamī outside of the Indo-Iranian pantheon, indirect parallels can be found in other Indo-European traditions. The Apsaras (water nymphs) can be compared to a variety of water deities (nymphs) in Greek mythology, such as the Naiads, or to the Slavic rusalki.
Downloads
References
Atharva-Veda Saṁhitā, trans. et comm. W.D. Whitney, ed. C.R. Lanman, vol. I–II, Cambridge Massachusetts 1905 [= Harvard Oriental Series, 7–8].
Google Scholar
Atharvaveda (Šaunaka), trans. et comm. T. Ja. Elizarenkova, vol. I–III, Moskva 2005–2010.
Google Scholar
Avesta. Die heiligen Bücher der Parsen, übersetzt auf der Grundlage von Chr. Bartholomae’s altiranischem Wörterbuch, trans. F. Wolff, Strasbourg 1910.
Google Scholar
Hymnes spéculatifs du Véda, trans. et comm. L. Renou, Paris 1956.
Google Scholar
Rigveda. Mandaly IX–X, trans. et comm. T.Ja. Elizarenkova, Moskva 1999.
Google Scholar
The Rigveda. The Earliest Religious Poetry of India, vol. I–III, trans. et comm. S.W. Jamison, J.P. Brereton, New York 2014.
Google Scholar
Der Rigveda oder die heiligen hymnen der Brâhmana, vol. I–II, trans. A. Ludwig, Prag 1876.
Google Scholar
Der Rigveda oder die heiligen hymnen der Brâhmana, vol. IV–V, Commentar zur Rigveda-übersetzung A. Ludwig, Prag–Leipzig 1883.
Google Scholar
The Rig Veda. An Anthology. One Hundred and Eight Hymns, trans. et comm. W. Doniger O’Flaherty, London 1981.
Google Scholar
Der Rig-Veda, vol. I–III, trans. et comm. K.F. Geldner, Cambridge Massachusetts 1951 [= Harvard Oriental Series, 33–35].
Google Scholar
Rig-Veda, vol. I–II, trans. et comm. H. Grassmann, Leipzig 1876–1877.
Google Scholar
Barnett L.D., Yama, Gandharva, and Glaucus, “Bulletin of the School of Oriental Studies” 4, 1928, p. 703–716.
Google Scholar
Belardi W., Consonanze mediterranee e asiatiche con il nome dei Centauri, “Studi e materiali di storia delle religioni” 20, 1996, p. 23–53.
Google Scholar
Black J., Green A., Gods, Demons and Symbols of Ancient Mesopotamia. An Illustrated Dictionary, London 1992.
Google Scholar
Bloomfield M., Contributions to the Interpretation of the Veda, “Journal of the American Oriental Society” 15, 1893, p. 143–188.
Google Scholar
Bodewitz H.W., The Dialogue of Yama and Yamī (R̥V. 10, 10), “Indo-Iranian Journal” 52, 2009, p. 251–285.
Google Scholar
Böhtlingk O., Roth R., Sanskrit-Wörterbuch, vol. I–VII, St. Petersburg 1855–1875.
Google Scholar
Bremmer J.N., Greek Demons of the Wilderness: the Case of the Centaurs, [in:] Wilderness in Mythology and Religion. Approaching Religious Spatialities, Cosmologies, and Ideas of Wild Nature, ed. L. Feldt, Berlin 2012, p. 25–53.
Google Scholar
Carnoy A.J., Iranian, [in:] The Mythology of All Races, vol. VI, Indian. Iranian, ed. L.H. Gray, G.F. Moore, Boston 1917, p. 251–351.
Google Scholar
Chantraine P. et al., Dictionnaire étymologique de la langue grecque. Histoire des mots, Paris 1968.
Google Scholar
Coomaraswamy A.K., Yakṣas, pars 1–2, Washington 1928–1931.
Google Scholar
Coulter C.R., Turner P., Encyclopedia of Ancient Deities, London 2000.
Google Scholar
De Angelis A., Tra dati linguistici e fonti letterarie: per un’etimologia del gr. κένταυρος ‘divoratore di viscere’, “Glotta” 85, 2009, p. 59–74.
Google Scholar
Doniger O’Flaherty W., On Hinduism, Oxford 2014.
Google Scholar
Doniger O’Flaherty W., Sacred Cows and Profane Mares in Indian Mythology, “History of Religions” 19, 1979, p. 1–26.
Google Scholar
Doniger O’Flaherty W., Women, Androgynes, and Other Mythical Beasts, Chicago 1980.
Google Scholar
duBois P., On Horse/Men, Amazons, and Endogamy, “Arethusa” 1979, 12, p. 35–49.
Google Scholar
Dumézil G., Le Problème des centaures. Étude de mythologie comparée indo-européenne, Paris 1929.
Google Scholar
Ehni J., Der Vedische Mythus des Yama verglichen mit den analogen Typen der Persischen, Griechischen und Germanischen Mythologie, Strassburg 1890.
Google Scholar
Frisk H., Griechisches etymologisches Worterbuch, Heidelberg 1960.
Google Scholar
Graysmith L., Sex and Gender in the Equine in Literature (unpublished MA thesis, Iowa State University, 2008).
Google Scholar
Haas C., Wie man den Veda lesen kann. Gandharva und die “Zwischenzustände” im R̥gveda und im Kommentar des Sāyaṇa. Wege der Interpretation eines archaischen Textes, Göttingen 2004 [= Historische Sprachforschung, 43].
Google Scholar
Hansen W.F., Handbook of Classical Mythology, Santa Barbara 2004.
Google Scholar
Ivanov V.V., Toporov V.N., K probleme lmš. jumis i baltijskogo bliznečnogo kul’ta, “Балто-славянские исследования” / “Balto-slavjanskie issledovanija” 1981, p. 140–175.
Google Scholar
Jackson P., The Transformations of Helen. Indo-European Myth and the Roots of the Trojan Cycle, Dettelbach 2006 [= Münchener Studien zur Sprachwissenschaft, 23].
Google Scholar
Jamison S.W., [rec.:] C. Haas, Wie man den Veda lesen kann… – “Journal of the American Oriental Society” 128, 2008, p. 394–395.
Google Scholar
Jaritz K., Die kassitischen Sprachreste, “Anthropos” 52, 1957, p. 850–898.
Google Scholar
Jespersen O., A Modern English Grammar on Historical Principles, pars 2, Syntax, vol. I, London–Copenhagen 1949.
Google Scholar
Ježić M., Rgvedski himni. Izvori indijske kulture i indoeuropsko nasljeđe, Zagreb 1987.
Google Scholar
Kellens J., Yima, magicien entre les dieux et les hommes, [in:] Orientalia J. Duchesne-Guillemin Oblata, Leuven–Leiden 1984 [= Acta Iranica, 23], p. 267–281.
Google Scholar
Kretschmer P., Mythische Namen. 9. Die Kentauren, “Glotta” 10, 1920, p. 50–58.
Google Scholar
Kuhn A., Gandharven und Kentauren, “Zeitschrift für Vergleichende Sprachforschung” 1.6, 1852, p. 513–542.
Google Scholar
Kuhn A., Saraṇyû – Ἐριννύς, “Zeitschrift für Vergleichende Sprachforschung” 1.5, 1852, p. 439–470.
Google Scholar
Kulikov L., Vedic āhanas- and Its Relatives/Cognates within and outside Indo-Iranian, [in:] Farnah. Indo-Iranian and Indo-European Studies in Honor of Sasha Lubotsky, Ann Arbor 2018, p. 153–161.
Google Scholar
Kulikov L., The Vedic particle ghā̆ reconsidered: Evidence from Vedic and beyond (forthcoming).
Google Scholar
Kulikov L., The Vedic -ya-presents. Passives and Intransitivity in Old Indo-Aryan, Amsterdam 2012 [= Leiden Studies in Indo-European, 19].
Google Scholar
Lanman C.R., A Statistical Account of Noun-inflection in the Veda, “Journal of the American Oriental Society” 10, 1880, p. 325–601.
Google Scholar
Lawrence E.A., The Centaur. Its History and Meaning in Human Culture, “Journal of Popular Culture” 27, 1994, p. 57–68.
Google Scholar
Lentz W., Yima and Khwarenah in the Avestan Gathas, [in:] A Locust’s Leg. Studies in Honour of S.H. Taqizadeh, ed. W.B. Henning, E. Yarshater, London 1962, p. 131–134.
Google Scholar
Lidke J.S., A Union of Fire and Water: Sexuality and Spirituality in Hinduism, [in:] Sexuality and the World’s Religions, ed. D.W. Machacek, M.M. Wilcox, Santa Barbara 2003.
Google Scholar
Lincoln B., The Lord of the Dead, “History of Religions” 20, 1981, p. 224–241.
Google Scholar
Lubotsky A., The Indo-Iranian Substratum, [in:] Early Contacts between Uralic and Indo-European. Linguistic and Archaeological Considerations, ed. C. Carpelan, A. Parpola, P. Koskikallio, Helsinki 2001 [=Mémoires de la Société Finno-ougrienne, 242], p. 301–317.
Google Scholar
Lubotsky A., RV.ávidhat, [in:] Früh‑, Mittel‑, Spätindogermanisch. Akten der IX. Fachtagung der Indogermanischen Gesellschaft vom 5. bis 9. Oktober 1992 in Zürich, ed. G. Dunkel et al., Wiesbaden 1994, p. 201–206.
Google Scholar
Macdonell A.A., Vedic mythology, Strassburg 1897.
Google Scholar
Malamoud C., Yama, Yamī et les diverses manières de former une paire, [in:] Yama/Yima. Variations indo-iraniennes sur la geste mythique = Variations on the Indo-Iranian myth of Yama/Yima, ed. S. Azarnouche, C. Redard, Paris 2012 [= Publications de l’Institut de Civilisation Indienne. Série in 8°, 81], p. 95–110.
Google Scholar
Masciadri V., Das Problem der Kentauren – die Griechen und das Wunderbare, [in:] Spinnenfuss und Krötenbauch: Genese und Symbolik von Kompositwesen, ed. P. Michel, Zürich 2013, p. 65–85.
Google Scholar
Maturo M., “Uomini-cavallo”: genesi, elaborazione e memoria iconografica della figura del centauro, alcuni esempi, “Acme” 2, 2014, p. 7–40.
Google Scholar
Mayrhofer M., EWAia = Etymologisches Wörterbuch des Altindoarischen, vol. I–III, Heidelberg 1986–2001.
Google Scholar
Mayrhofer M., Kurzgefastes etymologisches Wörterbuch des Altindischen = A Concise Etymological Sanskrit Dictionary, vol. I–IV, Heidelberg 1956–1980.
Google Scholar
Meyer E.H., Indogermanische Mythen, vol. I, Gandharven-Kentauren, Berlin 1883.
Google Scholar
Napol’ckich V.V., Kentavr ~ gandcharva ~ drakon ~ medved’: k evoljucii odnogo mifologičeskogo obraza v Severnoj Evrazii, “Nartamonga. The Journal of Alano-Ossetic Studies” 5, 2008, p. 43–63.
Google Scholar
Norman Brown W., [rec.:] A.K. Coomaraswamy, Yakṣas, pars 1–2, Washington 1928–1931, “Journal of the American Oriental Society” 51, 1931, p. 286–288.
Google Scholar
Odent M., Water and Sexuality, London 1990.
Google Scholar
Oettinger N., Before Noah: Possible Relics of the Flood-myth in Proto-Indo-Iranian and Earlier, [in:] Proceedings of the 24th Annual UCLA Indo-European Conference, ed. S.W. Jamison, H.C. Melchert, B. Vine, Bremen 2013, p. 169–183.
Google Scholar
Oldenberg H., R̥ gveda. Textkritische und exegetische Noten, vol. II, Siebentes bis zehntes Buch, Berlin 1912.
Google Scholar
Oldenberg H., Vedische Untersuchungen, “Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenländischen Gesellschaft” 63, 1909, p. 287–302.
Google Scholar
Pinault G.-J., Further Links between the Indo-Iranian Substratum and the BMAC Language, [in:] Themes and Tasks in Old and Middle Indo-Aryan linguistics, ed. B. Tikkanen, H. Hettrich, Delhi 2006, p. 167–196.
Google Scholar
Pinault G.-J., Sur l’hymne védique dialogué de Yama et Yamī(RV X.10), [in:] Yama/Yima. Variations indo-iraniennes sur la geste mythique = Variations on the Indo-Iranian myth of Yama/Yima, ed. S. Azarnouche, C. Redard, Paris 2012 [= Publications de l’Institut de Civilisation Indienne. Série in 8°, 81], p. 139–178.
Google Scholar
Pischel R., Vedische Studien, vol. I, Stuttgart 1889.
Google Scholar
Renou L., Études védiques et pāṇinéennes, vol. XVI, Paris 1967.
Google Scholar
Schnaus S., Die Dialoglieder im altindischen Rigveda. Kommentar unter besonderer Berücksichtigung textlinguistischer Kriterien, Hamburg 2008.
Google Scholar
Schneider T., Kassitisch und Hurro-Urartäisch: Ein Diskussionsbeitrag zu möglichen lexikalischen Isoglossen, “Altorientalische Forschungen” 30, 2003, p. 372–381.
Google Scholar
Schneider U., Yama und Yamī (R̥ V X 10), “Indo-Iranian Journal” 10, 1967, p. 1–32.
Google Scholar
Scobie A., The Origins of ‘Centaurs’, “Folklore” 89, 1978, p. 142–147.
Google Scholar
Shear I.M., Mycenaean Centaurs at Ugarit, “Journal of Hellenic Studies” 122, 2002, p. 147–153.
Google Scholar
Siklos B., The Evolution of the Buddhist Yama, [in:] The Buddhist Forum, vol. IV, ed. T. Skorupski, London 1996, p. 165–189.
Google Scholar
Skjærvø P.O., The Spirit of Zoroastrianism, New Haven–London 2011.
Google Scholar
Taheri A., The “Man-Bull” and the ≪Master of Animals≫ in Mesopotamia and in Iran, “International Journal of Humanities of the Islamic Republic of Iran” 20, 2013, p. 13–28.
Google Scholar
Thite U.G., Gandharvas and Apsarasas in the Veda, “Journal of the Indian Musicological Society” 18, 1987, p. 52–63.
Google Scholar
Thornton B.S., Eros. The Myth of Ancient Greek Sexuality, Boulder 1998.
Google Scholar
Uhlenbeck C.C., Kurzgefasstes etymologisches Wörterbuch der altindischen Sprache, Amsterdam 1898/1899.
Google Scholar
West M.L., Indo-European Poetry and Myth, Oxford 2007.
Google Scholar
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2018 Leonid Kulikov
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.