Garum or Grain? Crimea and the Provisioning of Constantinople (7th to 9th centuries)

Florin Curta

doi:10.18778/2084-140X.13.07

Authors

Florin Curta University of Florida, Department of History

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.18778/2084-140X.13.07

Keywords:

Crimea, lead seals, crop cultivation, silos, cereal seeds, agricultural implements, amphorae, fishing industry

Abstract

Historians have relied for too long on written sources (the letters that Pope Martin I wrote from Cherson, as well as De Administrando Imperio) to assess the economic situation in the Crimea, especially in Cherson, during the so-called Dark Ages (7th to 9th centuries). Many still believe that that city could not have survived without shipments of grain from the outside, particularly from the lands along the southern coast of the Black Sea. Seals of Byzantine officials found in Cherson tell a different story, as they indicate commercial exchanges between the Crimea and Constantinople. If the peninsula participated in trade, something must have been offered in exchange for the goods coming from the Capital. The archaeological evidence strongly suggests that during the 8th and 9th centuries, the hinterland of Cherson, as well as the Kerch Peninsula (eastern Crimea) witnessed rapid economic development, largely based on the cultivation of crops. Silos found on several settlement sites, both open and fortified, suggest a surplus, which was most likely commercialized. If so, the closest markets were across the Black Sea, to the south, primarily in Constantinople. Other commodities, such as wine transported in amphorae, traveled in the opposite direction, across the Sea of Azov and into the interior of Khazaria. In exchange, the peninsula received shipments of grain, which were then re-exported to Constantinople. Far from relying on shipments of grain from the Capital, Cherson and the rest of the Crimean Peninsula in fact supplied Constantinople with food. Numerous vats for the production of fish sauce have been found in Cherson, and many were in operation before 900. A good deal of the garum served at tables in Constantinople between the 7th and the 9th century must have come from Cherson. The archaeological evidence therefore calls for a re-assessment of the economic situation in the Crimean Peninsula during the “Dark Ages”.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Chronographiae quae Theophanis Continuati nomine fertur libri I–IV, ed. et trans. M. Featherstone, J. Signes Codoñer, Berlin–Boston 2015 [= Corpus fontium historiae byzantinae. Series Berolinensis, 53].
Google Scholar

Constantine Porphyrogenitus, De administrando imperio, ed. G. Moravcsik, trans. R.J.H. Jenkins, 2 Washington D.C. 1967 [= Corpus fontium historiae byzantinae, 1; Dumbarton Oaks Texts, 1].
Google Scholar

Seventh-Century Popes and Martyrs. The Political Hagiography of Anastasius Bibliothecarius, ed. et trans. B. Neil, Turnhout 2006 [= Studia Antiqua Australiensia, 2].
Google Scholar

Aibabin A.I., On Byzantium’s Northern Border. The Rural Population of the Mountainous Crimea in the 6th to 9th centuries, [in:] Les villages dans l’Empire byzantin, IVe–XVe siècles, ed. J. Lefort, C. Morrisson, J.-P. Sodini, Paris 2005 [= Réalités Byzantines, 11], p. 415–424.
Google Scholar

Ajbabin A.I., Na granice Vizantijskoj imperii i Chazarskogo kaganata. Konec VII–IX v., [in:] Istoriia Kryma, vol. I, ed. A.V. Iurasov, Moskva 2019, p. 236–265.
Google Scholar

Ajbabin A.I., Usad’ba rybaka v rannevizantijskom Bospore, [in:] Problemy istorii i archeologii srednevekovogo Kryma. Materialy meždunarodnoj naučnoj konferencii posviaščennoj 70-letiiu Aleksandra Il’iča Ajbabina. Simferopol’, 10–11 ianvaria 2019 g., ed. E.A. Chajredinova, Simferopol’ 2019, p. 7–17.
Google Scholar

Aksenov V.S., Micheev V.K., Krymskij import i chronologija nekotorych saltovskich pamiatnikov verchovij Severskogo Donca, [in:] Kul’tury evraziiskich stepej vtoroj poloviny I tysiačeletija n.e. (voprosy chronologij). Materialy II Meždunarodnoj arkheologičeskoj konferencii, 17–20 nojabrja 1997 g., ed. D.A. Stašenkov, A.F. Kočkina, L.V. Kuznecova, Samara 1998, p. 344–357.
Google Scholar

Albrecht S., Cherson als Zentralort auf der südwestlichen Krim (6.–10. Jahrhundert), [in:] Grenz Übergänge. Spätrömisch, frühchristlich, frühbyzantinisch als Kategorien der historisch-archäologischen Forschung an der mittleren Donau. Akten des 27. internationalen Symposiums der Grundprobleme der frühgeschichtlichen Entwicklung im mittleren Donauraum, Ruma, 4.–7.11.2015, ed. I. Bugarski, O. Heinrich-Tamáska, V. Ivanišević, D. Syrbe, Remshalden 2016 [= Forschungen zu Spätantike und Mittelalter, 4], p. 355–384.
Google Scholar

Albrecht S., Quellen zur Geschichte der byzantinischen Krim, Mainz 2012 [= Monographien des Römisch-Germanischen Zentralmuseums, 101].
Google Scholar

Alekseenko N.A., Činovniki Balkano-maloazijskogo regiona na molivdovulach Chersonskogo archiva, [in:] Numizmatični i sfragistični prinosi kăm istoriiata na zapadnoto Černomorie. Meždunarodna konferenciia, Varna, 12–15 septemvri 2001 g., ed. V. Jotov, I. Lazarenko, Varna 2004 [= Acta Musei Varnensis, 2], p. 265–275.
Google Scholar

Alekseenko N.A., L’administration byzantine de Cherson. Catalogue des sceaux, Paris 2012 [= Occasional Monographs, 4].
Google Scholar

Alekseenko N.A., Les relations entre Cherson et l’empire, d’après le témoignage des sceaux des archives de Cherson, “Studies in Byzantine Sigillography” 8, 2003, p. 75–83, https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110960082.75
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110960082.75

Alekseenko N.A., Molivdovuly adressantov Chersona VII–IX vv. (novye nachodki), “Древности” / “Drevnosti” 1996, p. 122–133.
Google Scholar

Alekseenko N.A., Sfragistyka bizantyńska. Molibdobule Chersonu, Poznań 2015.
Google Scholar

Aržanov A.Iu., Vinodelie v bližnej okruge rannesrednevekovogo Chersona, “Херсонесский сборник” / “Chersonesskij sbornik” 21, 2020, p. 108–133.
Google Scholar

Baranov I.A., Tavrika v èpochu rannego srednevekov’ia (saltovo-maiackaja kul’tura), Kiev 1990.
Google Scholar

Boltrik Iu.V., Komar O.V., Chazarskij kurgan na pravom beregu r. Moločnoj, [in:] Dnepro-donskoe meždureč’e v èpochu rannego srednevekov’ia (sbornik statej), ed. A.Z. Vinnikov, Voronež 2005, p. 82–93.
Google Scholar

Borodin O.R., Rimskii papa Martin I i ego pisma iz Kryma (stat’ia, perevod, kommentarij), [in:] Pričernomor’e v srednie veka. K XVIII Meždunarodnomu kongressu vizantinistov, ed. S.P. Karpov, Moskva 1991, p. 173–190.
Google Scholar

Brubaker L., Haldon J., Byzantium in the Iconoclast Era (c. 680–850), Cambridge–New York 2011.
Google Scholar

Čechová M., Fish Products and their Trade in Tauric Chersonesos/Byzantine Cherson. The Development of a Traditional Craft from Antiquity to the Middle Ages, [in:] Detlefsen zum 100. Todestag. Ein Colloquium der Detlefsen-Gesellschaft Glückstadt, ed. Chr. Boldt, K.-J. Lorenzen-Schmidt, Borsfleth 2014, p. 229–236.
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/books.pccj.1746

Čechová M., Silk on the Northern Border of Byzantium: Intentions, Possibilities, Findings, “Byzantinoslavica” 80.1–2, 2022, p. 88–107.
Google Scholar

Choref M.M., K voprosu ob atribucii monogramm na gemifolisach Chersona pervoj poloviny IX v., “Причерноморье. История, политика, культура” / “Pričernomor’e. Istoriia, politika, kul’tura” 3, 2010, p. 121–125.
Google Scholar

Choref M.M., Monetnoe delo Khersona v pervoj polovine VIII v., “Материалы по археологии и истории античного и средневекового Крыма” / “Materialy po arkheologii i istorii antičnogo i srednevekovnogo Kryma” 2, 2010, p. 192–197.
Google Scholar

Csiky G., Sinope in the Early Medieval Economy of the Black Sea Region (Questions and Problems), “Antaeus” 33, 2015, p. 315–345.
Google Scholar

Curta F., The Long Sixth century in Eastern Europe, Leiden–Boston 2021 [= East Central and Eastern Europe in the Middle Ages, 450–1450, 72], https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004456983
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004456983

Decker M.J., The Byzantine Dark Ages, London–New York 2016.
Google Scholar

Gadlo A.V., Rannesrednevekovoe selišče na beregu Kerčenskogo proliva (po materialam raskopok 1963 g.), “Краткие сообщения Института Археологи Академии наук СССР” / “Kratkie soobsščenija Instituta Archeologij Akademii Nauk SSSR” 113, 1968, p. 78–84.
Google Scholar

Gadlo A.V., Raskopki rannesrednevekovogo selišča u derevni Geroevka, “Советская археология” / “Sovetskaja Archeologija” 1, 1969, p. 160–168.
Google Scholar

Gajdukevič V.F., Raskopki Tiritaki v 1935–1940 gg., [in:] Bosporskie goroda, ed. V.F. Gajdukevič, M.I. Maksimova, Moskva 1952 [= Материалы и исследования по археологии СССР / Materialy i issledovaniia po arkheologii SSSR, 25], p. 15–134.
Google Scholar

Grib V.K., Dobroe Pole – pamiatnik rannesrednevekovogo vremeni v severo-vostočnoi časti Doneckogo krjaža, “Донецкий археологiчний збiрник” / “Doneckij archeologichnji zbirnyk” 18–19, 2014–2015, p. 286–300.
Google Scholar

Gus’kov A., Atlas pesščernych gorodov Kryma. Putešestvie k stroiteliam i obitateliam peščer, Charkiv 2007.
Google Scholar

Jakobson A.L., Rannesrednevekovye sel’skie poselenija Iugo-Zapadnoi Tavriki, Leningrad 1970.
Google Scholar

Koder J., Stew and Salted Meat – Opulent Normality in the Diet of the Every Day?, [in:] Eat, Drink and be Merry (Luke 12:19). Food and Wine in Byzantium. Papers of the 37th Annual Spring Symposium of Byzantine Studies in Honour of Professor A.A.M. Bryer, ed. L. Brubaker, K. Linardou, Aldershot–Burlington 2007, p. 59–72.
Google Scholar

Koloda V.V., Gorbanenko S.A., Agriculture in the Forest-Steppe Region of Khazaria, Leiden–Boston 2020 [= East Central and Eastern Europe in the Middle Ages, 450–1450, 66], https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004429574
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004429574

Laiou A.E., Morrisson C., The Byzantine Economy, Cambridge–New York 2007, https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511816727
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511816727

Lichačev N.P., Datirovannye vizantiiskie pečati, “Известия Российской Академии истории материальнои культуры” / “Izvestija Rossijskoj Akademii istorii material’noi kul’tury” 3, 1924, p. 153–224.
Google Scholar

Lifanov N.A., “Knjažeskij” kurgan na Samarskoj Luke: voprosy kul’turno-chronologičeskoj atribucii, “Эпохи” / “Epokhi” 25.1, 2017, p. 92–119.
Google Scholar

Makarova T.I., Ajbabin A.I., Krym v VIII–IX vekach. Chazarskoe gospodstvo, [in:] Krym, severo-vostočnoe Pričernomor’e i Zakavkaz’e v epochu srednevekov’ja, IV–XIII veka, ed. T.I. Makarova, S.A. Pletneva, Moskva 2003, p. 53–67.
Google Scholar

Marti V.Iu., Rybozasoločnye vanny Tiritaki, [in:] Archeologičeskie pamiatniki Bospora i Chersonesa, ed. S.A. Žebelev, V.F. Gajdukevič, Moskva–Leningrad 1941, p. 93–95.
Google Scholar

McCormick M., Origins of the European Economy. Communications and Commerce, AD 300–900, Cambridge 2001, https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781107050693
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781107050693

Neil B., From tristia to gaudia. The Exile and Martyrdom of Pope Martin I, [in:] Martyrdom and Persecution in Late Antique Christianity. Festschrift Boudewijn Dehandschutter, ed. J. Leemans, Leuven–Paris–Walpole 2010, p. 179–194.
Google Scholar

Nidzel’nickaja L.Iu., Il’jashenko S.M., Rannesrednevekovye poselenie na territorij Tanaisa, [in:] Srednevekovye drevnosti Dona, ed. Iu.K. Guguev, Moskva–Jerusalem 2007 [= Материалы и исследования по археологии Дона / Materialy i issledovanija po archeologij Dona, 2], p. 193–214.
Google Scholar

Očir-Goriaeva M.A., Sitdikov A.G., Kijaško Ja.A., Naga T., K izučeniju pamiatnika èpochi rannego srednevekov’ia Bašanta-II, “Поволжская археология” / “Povolžskaja archeologija” 4, 2016, p. 23–36.
Google Scholar

Petrauskas A.V., Volyncevs’kij kompleks rann’oslov’jans’kogo poselennja Obukhiv 2, “Археологiя” / “Archeologija” 1, 2019, p. 67–82.
Google Scholar

Ponomarev L.Iu, Choziajstvennaia deiatel’nost’ naselenija saltovskoj kul’tury Kerčenskogo poluostrova (kratkij obzor archeologičeskich istočnikov), “Салтово-маяцька археологiчна культура: проблеми та дослiдження” / “Saltovo-maiac’ka archeologična kul’tura: problemy ta doslidžennia” 2, 2012, p. 67–79.
Google Scholar

Ponomarev L.Iu., Saltovo-maiackie poselenija kerčenskogo poluostrova (kratkij obzor po archeologičeskim dannym), “Хазарский альманах” / “Chazarskij al’manach” 12, 2014, p. 135–159.
Google Scholar

Ponomarev L.Iu., Saltovo-maiackoe poselenie Geroevka-3 na Kerčenskom poluostrove (po materialam raskopok A.V. Gadlo 1963 g.), “История и археология Крыма” / “Istorija i archeologija Kryma” 1, 2014, p. 376–399.
Google Scholar

Romančuk A.I., Chersonesos und sein ländliches Territorium im 8./9. Jahrhundert, [in:] Studien zum 8. und 9. Jahrhundert in Byzanz, ed. H. Köpstein, F. Winkelmann, Berlin 1983 [= Berliner Byzantinistische Arbeiten, 51], p. 35–45, https://doi.org/10.1515/9783112651421-004
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/9783112651421-004

Romančuk A.I., Gorod i derevnia iugo-zapadnogo Kryma v 8–9 vv., [in:] XVI. internationaler Byzantinistenkongreß. Akten. II, vol. III, ed. W. Hörandner, C. Cupane, E. Kislinger, Wien 1982 (= “Jahrbuch der österreichischen Byzantinistik” 32.3), p. 549–559.
Google Scholar

Romančuk A.I., Novye materialy o vremeni stroitel’stva rybozasoločnych cistern v Chersonese, “Античная древность и средние века” / “Antičnaja drevnost’ i srednie veka” 9, 1973, p. 45–53.
Google Scholar

Romančuk A.I., Plan rybozasoločnych cistern Chersonesa, “Античная древность и средние века” /“Antičnaja drevnost’ i srednie veka” 14, 1977, p. 18–26.
Google Scholar

Romančuk A.I., Studien zur Geschichte und Archäologie des byzantinischen Cherson, Leiden–Boston 2005 [= Colloquia Pontica, 11], https://doi.org/10.1163/9789047404682
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/9789047404682

Romančuk A.I., Omel’kova L.A., Srednevekovoe poselenie na levom beregu reki Bel’bek, “Античная древность и средние века” / “Antičnaja drevnost’ i srednie veka” 16, 1979, p. 94–104.
Google Scholar

Romančuk A.I., Sazanov A.V., Sedikova L.V., Amfory iz kompleksov vizantijskogo Chersona, Ekaterinburg 1995.
Google Scholar

Sazanov A.V., Globuliarnye amfory pričernomorskogo tipa (Crimean Globular Amphorae) i problemy chronologij kompleksov VIII–IX vv., [in:] Trudy VI (XXII) Vserossijskogo archeologičeskogo s’’ezda v Samare, vol. II, ed. A.P. Derevianko, N.A. Malarov, O.D. Močalov, Samara 2020, p. 266–268.
Google Scholar

Sazanov A.V., Goroda i poselenija Severnogo Pričernomor’ja rannevizantijskogo vremeni (Ph.D. dissertation, State University of Moscow, Moscow 1999).
Google Scholar

Sazanov A.V., La campagne et les villages en Crimée à l’époque protobyzantine: chronologie et évolution, [in:] XXe Congrès international des études byzantines, Collège de France-Sorbonne, 19–25 août 2001. Pré-actes, Paris 2001, p. 222.
Google Scholar

Skorikov I.A., Keramičeskij kompleks Krymskogo gorodišča na amfornom materiale 2011 goda, [in:] IX Meždunarodnaja archeologičeskaja konferencija studentov i aspirantov “Problemy archeologii Vostočnoj Evropy” (materialy konferencii), ed. E.V. Vdovčenkov, Rostov-na-Donu 2014, p. 85–88.
Google Scholar

Sokolova I.V., Vizantijskie pečati VI-pervoj poloviny IX v. iz Chersonesa, “Византийский временник” / “Vizantijskij Vremennik” 52, 1991, p. 201–213.
Google Scholar

Soročan S.B., O torgovo-ekonomičeskoj politike Vizantij v Tavrike VII–IX vv., [in:] Problemy archeologij drevnego i srednevekovogo Kryma. Sbornik naučnych trudov, ed. Iu.M. Mogarčev, I.N. Khrapunov, Simferopol’ 1995, p. 114–122.
Google Scholar

Soročan S.B., Vizantijskij Cherson (vtoraja polovina VI-pervaja polovina X vv.). Očerki istorii i kul’tury, Moskva 2013.
Google Scholar

Soročan S.B., Zubar’ V.M., Marčenko L.V., Žizn’ i gibel’ Chersonesa, Sevastopol’ 2006.
Google Scholar

Stepanova E.V., Novye nachodki iz Sudakskogo archiva pečatej, [in:] Surož, Sugdeja, Soldaija v istorij i kul’ture Rusi-Ukrainy. Materialy naučnoj konferencii (16–22 sentiabrja 2002 g.), ed. N.M. Kukoval’skaja, A.M. Farbej, V.I. Zubar’, G.Iu. Ivakin, I.E. Margolina, O.P. Motsia, M.V. Pančenko, Kiev–Sudak 2002, p. 231–233.
Google Scholar

Stepanova E.V., Sudakskij archiv pečatej: predvaritel’nye vyvody, “Античная древность и средние века” / “Antičnaja drevnost’ i srednie veka” 32, 2001, p. 97–108.
Google Scholar

Stepanova E.V., Šandrovskaja V.S., Esšče raz o Sudakskom archive pečatej, “Античная древность и средние века” / “Antičnaja drevnost’ i srednie veka” 35, 2004, p. 295–297.
Google Scholar

Suprenkov A.A., Naumenko V.E., Ponomarev L.Iu., Poselenie VIII–X vv. Gora Čirkova 1 na Tamanskom poluostrove: choziajstvennye kompleksy gruppy 2 (po materialam raskopok 2015 g.), “История и археология Крыма” / “Istorija i archeologija Kryma” 12, 2020, p. 221–268.
Google Scholar

Tarabanov A.V., Poselenija bolgar na pravoberež’ie Kubani, [in:] Drevnosti Kubani i Černomor’ja, ed. A.V. P’iankov, N.F. Ševčenko, Krasnodar 1993 [= Studia Pontocaucasica, 1], p. 115–122.
Google Scholar

Teall J.L., The Grain Supply of the Byzantine Empire, 330–1025, “Dumbarton Oaks Papers” 13, 1959, p. 87–139, https://doi.org/10.2307/1291130
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/1291130

Wickham C., Framing the Early Middle Ages. Europe and the Mediterranean, 400–800, Oxford 2005, https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199264490.001.0001
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199264490.001.0001

Zavagno L., The Byzantine City from Heraclius to the Fourth Crusade, 610–1204. Urban Life after Antiquity, Cham 2021, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-84307-6
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-84307-6

Zin’ko V.N., Novye rannesrednevekovye pamiatniki Vostočnogo Kryma, [in:] Meždunarodnaja konferencija “Vizantija i Krym”, Sevastopol’, 6–11 iunja 1997 g. Tezisy dokladov, Simferopol’ 1997, p. 40–41.
Google Scholar

Zin’ko A.V., Zin’ko V.N., Voprosy topografii goroda Bospora v rannevizantijskoe vremja, [in:] Vizantija v kontekste mirovoj kul’tury. Materialy konferencii, posviaščennoj pamiati Alisy Vladimirovny Bank, 1906–1984, ed. V.N. Zalesskaja, E.V. Stepanova, A.A. Jerusalimskaja, Iu.A. Pjatnickij, V.S. Šandrovskaja, Sankt-Peterburg 2017 [= Труды Государственного Эрмитажа / Trudy Gosudarstvennogo Ermitazha, 89], p. 164–176.
Google Scholar