The alchemy of human variation: Race, ethnicity and Manoiloff’s blood reaction
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.2478/v10044-008-0002-8Keywords:
race, typologyAbstract
This paper examines the research on race determination conducted by Russian biochemist E.O. Manoiloff in the 1920s. Manoiloff claimed to have discovered a method which detected racial identity of an individual by a simple chemical reaction performed on a subject's blood sample. The method was published in one of the leading anthropological journals and it was not questioned for some time. It is obvious today that Manoiloff's claims were nothing short of ridiculous. The present study, based on the experimental history of sciences, tries to elucidate Manoiloff's procedures and reasons for his ‘success’. His experiments were repeated using both original and modern equipment. It has been demonstrated that Manoiloff's procedures, although rigorous at first glance, were highly arbitrary and methodologically flawed. It would appear that the socio-political and scientific contexts of the early twentieth century which favoured belief in the existence of clearly distinguishable racial types played a crucial role in the initial positive response to Manoiloff's research.
Downloads
References
Abromavich C.E. Jr., W. Gardner Lynn, 1930, Sex, species, and race discrimination by Manoilov's methods, Q. Rev. Biol., 5, 68-78.
View in Google Scholar
Barkan E., 1992, The Retreat of Scientific Racism: Changing Concepts of Race in Britain and the United States between the World Wars, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
View in Google Scholar
Biondi G., O. Rickards, 2002, The scientific fallacy of the human biological concept of race, Mankind Quart., 42, 355-388.
View in Google Scholar
Brace C.L., 2005, Race is a Four-Letter Word: The Genesis of the Concept, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
View in Google Scholar
Cartmill M., 1998, The status of the race concept in physical anthropology, Am. Anthropol., 100, 651-660.
View in Google Scholar
Cavalli-Sforza L.L., P. Menozzi, A. Piazza, 1994, The History and Geography of Human Genes, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
View in Google Scholar
Ellison G.T.H., A.H. Goodman (eds.), 2006, The Nature of Human Difference: Science, Society and Human Biology, CRC Press, London.
View in Google Scholar
Falk K.G., J. Lorberblatt, 1927, A chemical study of the Manoilov test for the differentiation of sexes, Brit. J. Exp. Biol,.4, 305-312.
View in Google Scholar
Gould S.J., 1978, Morton's ranking of races by cranial capacity, Science, 200, 503-509.
View in Google Scholar
Gould S.J., 1981, The Mismeasure of Man, W.W. Norton, New York and London.
View in Google Scholar
Hooton E.A., 1931, Up from the Ape, Macmillan, New York.
View in Google Scholar
Hirschfeld M., 1938, Racism, Victor Gollancz, London.
View in Google Scholar
Kaszycka K.A., J. Strzałko, 2003a, ‘Race’ - Still an issue for physical anthropology? Results of Polish studies seen in the light of the U.S. findings, Am. Anthropol., 105, 116-124.
View in Google Scholar
Kaszycka K.A., J. Strzałko, 2003b, Race: Tradition and convenience, or taxonomic reality? More on the race concept in Polish anthropology, Przegląd Antropologiczny - Anthropological Review, 66, 23-37.
View in Google Scholar
Kaszycka K.A., G. Štrkalj, 2002, Anthropologist's attitudes towards the concept of race: The Polish sample, Curr. Anthropol., 43, 329-335.
View in Google Scholar
Kohn M., 1995, The Race Gallery: The Return of Racial Science, Jonathan Cape, London.
View in Google Scholar
Kragh H., 1987, An Introduction to the Historiography of Science, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
View in Google Scholar
Lieberman L., K.A. Kaszycka, A.J. Martinez Fuentes, L. Yablonski, R.C. Kirk, G. Štrkalj, Q. Wang, L. Sun, 2004, The race concept in five regions: Variations without consensus, Collegium Antropol., 28, 907-921.
View in Google Scholar
Lieberman L, B.W. Stevenson, L.T. Reynolds, 1989, Race and anthropology: A core concept without consensus, Anthropol. Educ. Quart., 20, 67-73.
View in Google Scholar
Manoiloff E.O., 1927, Discernment of human races by blood. Particularly of Russians from Jews, Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 10, 11-21.
View in Google Scholar
Manoilov E.O., 1924, Weitere Erfahrungen über meine chemische Blutreaktion zur Geschlechtsbestimmung bei Menschen, Tieren und durch Chlorphyll bei Pflanzen, Münch. Med. Wochenshr, 71, 1784-1789.
View in Google Scholar
Manoilov E.O., 1929, Chemical reaction of blood for definition of sex in man, animals, and dioecious plants. Third modification, Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 13, 29-68.
View in Google Scholar
Marks J., 1994, Blood will tell (won't it): A century of molecular discourse in anthropological systematics, Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 94, 59-79.
View in Google Scholar
Marks J., 1995, Human Biodiversity: Genes, Race, and History, Aldine de Gruyter, New York.
View in Google Scholar
Nelkin D., M.S. Lindee, 1995, The DNA Mystique: The Gene as a Cultural Icon, W.H. Freeman, New York.
View in Google Scholar
Poliakowa A.T., 1927, Manoiloff's ‘race’ reaction and its application to the determination of paternity, Am. J. Phys. Anthropol., 10, 23-29.
View in Google Scholar
Satina S., M. Demerec, 1927, Manoilov's reaction for identification of sexes, Science, 62, 225-226.
View in Google Scholar
Simpson W.G., 2003, Which Way Western Man?, (2nd edition), National Vanguard Books, Hillsboro.
View in Google Scholar
Stepan N., 1982, The Idea of Race in Science: Great Britain 1800-1960, Archon Press, Hamden.
View in Google Scholar
Stocking G.W. Jr., 1968, Race, Culture, and Evolution: Essays in the History of Anthropology, Free Press, New York.
View in Google Scholar
Verschuer O.F. von, 1938, Rassenbiologie der Juden, Forschungen zur Judenfrage, 3, 15-46.
View in Google Scholar
Wang Q., G. Štrkalj, L. Sun, 2002, The status of the race concept in Chinese biological anthropology, Anthropologie (Brno), 40, 95-98.
View in Google Scholar
Wolpoff M.H., R. Caspari, 1997, Race and Human Evolution: A Fatal Attraction, Simon and Schuster, New York.
View in Google Scholar
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.