The rescue of Jews from the Nazi genocide by the inhabitants of Eastern Galicia

Igor Shchupak

doi:10.18778/1231-1952.28.1.04

Authors

Igor Shchupak “Tkuma” Ukrainian Institute for Holocaust Studies, Museum “Jewish Memory and Holocaust in Ukraine”, 4, Sholom-Aleichem St., Dnipro, Ukraine, 49000, Ukraine https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6877-6740

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.18778/1231-1952.28.1.04

Keywords:

Righteous Among the Nations, Jew rescuers, the Holocaust, ghetto, auxiliary police, Andrey Sheptytsky

Abstract

The rescue of Jews during the Second World War is one of the least studied issues in the historiography of the Holocaust. The Galicia Region, one of the areas where a total Nazi extermination of Jews occurred, became a region from where a large number of Righteous Among the Nations came – Ukrainians and Poles.

The article includes an analysis of the motivations that became the basis for people’s decision to help Jews under the extreme conditions which threatened their lives and the lives of their close ones. It highlights the response of the occupation authorities to rescue actions taken by the non-Jewish population. Despite the unambiguity of the Nazi orders to punish severely those who helped Jews, the real implementation of such sanctions varied.

Finally, the article analyses the main determinants (of social, economic, and religious nature) that played an important role in making the decision whether to join the rescue process.

The article concludes that no political which could had saved Jews, did lead to any systematic rescue efforts directed at Western Ukrainian Jews, yet the survival of those Jews who were hunter was possible for the deeds of some Polish and Ukrainian people.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

ALTMAN, I. A. (2002), Kholokost i evreyskoe Soprotivlenie na okkupirovannoy territorii SSSR, Moscow.
Google Scholar

ARENDT, Kh. (2013), Banalnist zla. Sud nad Aikhmanom v Yerusalymi, Kyiv.
Google Scholar

BERKHOF, K. (2011), Zhnyva rozpachu. Zhyttia i smert v Ukraini pid natsystskoiu vladoiu [Harvest of Despair: Life and Death in Ukraine under Nazi Rule], translated from English by T. Tsymbal, Kyiv.
Google Scholar

Blazhennyi arkhimandryt Klymentiy (2017), (Casimir Count Sheptytsky): Letters to brother Stanislav Count Sheptytsky and family. 1881–1945, Lviv.
Google Scholar

BOCIURKIW, B. R. (1989), ‘Sheptyts’kyi and the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church Under the Soviet Occupation of 1939–1941’, [in:] MAGOCSI, P.-R. and KRAWCHUK, A. (eds.) Morality and Reality. The Life and Times of Andrei Sheptyts’kyi, Edmonton: Canadian Institute of Ukrainian Studies, pp. 101–123.
Google Scholar

BUDZ, K. (2019), ‘Perezhyty Holokost u Skhidniy Halychyni: aktsiyi poryatunku Hreko-Katolytsʹkoyi Tserkvy u svidchennyakh rabyna Davyda Kahane ta Kurta Levina’, Problemy Istoriyi Holokostu: Ukrayinsʹkyy Vymir, 11, Dnipro: “Tkuma”: “Lira LTD”, pp. 186–205. https://doi.org/10.33124/hsuf.2019.11.08
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.33124/hsuf.2019.11.08

CHAIKA, T. (2007). ‘Kolaboratsiia u “prostori smerti”: do osmyslennia moralnoi kolizii Mytropolyta Andreia Sheptytskoho’, Problems of the Holocaust History: Scientific Journal, 4, pp. 100–113.
Google Scholar

Derzhavnyi arkhiv Lvivskoi oblasti (DALO) [The State Archive of the Lviv Region], FR-77. Inventory 1. Files: 309; 366; 502; 504; 574; 592; 654; 661; 735; 758; 759; 791; 800; 847; 851; 904; 1111; 1227; 1258; 1358.
Google Scholar

Derzhavnyi arkhiv Zaporizkoi oblasti (DAZO) [The State Archive of the Zaporizhzhia Region], FR-1849. Inventory 1. File 1.
Google Scholar

DJUKOV, A. (2008), Vtorostepennyj vrag. OUN, UPA i reshenie “evrejskogo voprosa”: Monografija, Moscow: REGNUM.
Google Scholar

GOGUN, A. and GINDA, V. (2011), ‘Skvoz’ prizmu dokumentov zavoevatelej’, Holokost i Suchasnist: Naukovyi Chasopys, 1 (9).
Google Scholar

GUTMAN, I. and GALIL’, N. [n.d.]. Katastrofa i pamyat o ney, translated from Hebrew by Z. Kopel’man and J. Sinichkin, Jerusalem: Yad Vashem.
Google Scholar

HON, M. M. (2010), ‘Variatyvnist rolei sposterihachiv u chas realizatsii henotsydalnoho protsesu’, Istorychni uroky Holokostu ta Mizhnatsionalni Vidnosyny: Zbirnyk Naukovykh Prats, Dnipropetrovsk: Tsentr “Tkuma”.
Google Scholar

HRYTSAK, Ya. (2017), ‘Yak ukraintsi perekhovuvaly yevreiv’, https://www.obozrevatel.com/society/15436-yak-ukraintsi-perehovuvali-evreiv.htm [accessed on: 10.04.2019].
Google Scholar

Iz svidetel’stva M. Burshtejn ob unichtozhenii evreev poselka Lenindorf (Ukraina, 1941 g.), (2003), [in:] KARDASH, A. compiler. Holokost. Ubijstvo Evreev v 1933–1945 gg. Antologija, Moscow: Daat/Znanie.
Google Scholar

KASIANOV, H. (2004), ‘Ideolohiia OUN: istoryko-retrospektyvnyi analiz’, Ukrainian Historical Journal, 1, p. 29–42.
Google Scholar

KOVAL, M. V. (1992), ‘Natsystskyi henotsyd shchodo yevreiv ta ukrainske naselennia (1941–1944 rr.)’, Ukrainian Historical Journal, 2, p. 27.
Google Scholar

KOVBA, Zh. (2007), ‘Vplyv mytropolyta Sheptytskoho na virnykh u chasy Holokostu’, Problems of the Holocaust History: Scientific Journal, 4, pp. 127–151.
Google Scholar

KOVBA, Zh. M., (2009), Liudianist u bezodni pekla. Povedinka mistsevoho naselennia Skhidnoi Halychyny v roky “ostatochnoho rozviazannia yevreiskoho pytannia”, 3rd edition, revised and enlarged. Kyiv: Dukh i Litera.
Google Scholar

KOVBA, Zh. M. (2009), Ostannii rabyn Lvova Yezekiil Levin, Lviv−Kyiv.
Google Scholar

Litopys UPA, (1992), Medychna opika v UPA: Dokumenty, materiialy i spohady, 23, Toronto–Lviv: Litopys UPA.
Google Scholar

Lviv. Local guards escorting a Jewish convoy, Yad Vashem the World Holocaust Remembrance Center, https://www.yadvashem.org/education/other-languages/ukrainian/educational-materials/lvov.html
Google Scholar

MARYNOVYCH, M. (2007), ‘Postat Mytropolyta Sheptytskoho u neliniinomu prostori istorychnoho chasu’, Problems of the Holocaust History: Scientific Journal, 4, pp. 81–87.
Google Scholar

MATKOVSKYI, I. (2019), Kazymyr hraf Sheptytsʹkyy – otetsʹ Klymentiy: polʹsʹkyy arystokrat, ukrayinsʹkyy iyeromonakh, Ekzarkh Rosiyi ta Sybiru, Arkhimandryt Studytiv, Pravednyk narodiv svitu, blazhennyy Katolytsʹkoyi Tserkvy: Monografija, Lviv.
Google Scholar

Metropolitan Archbishop Andrey Sheptytsky, Canadian Institute of Ukrainian Studies, Internet Encyclopedia of Ukraine, http://www.encyclopediaofukraine.com/display.asp?linkpath=pages%5CS%5CH%5CSheptytskyAndrei.htm
Google Scholar

Mytropolyt Andrei Sheptytskyi. Dokumenty i materialy: 1941–1944, (2003), compiler Zh. Kovba; ed. A. Kravchuk. Kyiv.
Google Scholar

NAKHMANOVYCH, V. (2016), ‘Babyn Yar: mistse pamiati u poshukakh maibutnoho’, [in:] HRYNEVYCH, V. and MAGOCSI, P.-R. (eds.) Babyn Yar: Istoriia i pamiat, Kyiv: Dukh i Litera.
Google Scholar

Names and Numbers of Righteous Among the Nations – per Country & Ethnic Origin, as of 1 January 2017. Yad Vashem, https://www.yadvashem.org/righteous/statistics.html [accessed on 15.04.2019].
Google Scholar

O Pravednikah, (2018), Yad Vashem, http://www1.yadvashem.org/yv/ru/righteous/about.asp [accessed on: 10.04.2019].
Google Scholar

Oholoshennia Hebitskomisaru, Dnipro: Arkhiv Tsentru “Tkuma”.
Google Scholar

Oholoshennia heneral-hubernatora Franka (Varshava, October, 15, 1941 r.) ta shtadhauptmana Kholera (Lviv, March, 10, 1942 r.), Dnipro: Arkhiv Tsentru “Tkuma”.
Google Scholar

PALDIEL, M. (n.d.), Pravedniki Narodov Mira v gody Katastrofy, Yad Vashem, http://www.yad-vashem.org/yv/ru/education/lesson_plans/pdf/righteous1.pdf [accessed on 10.04.2019].
Google Scholar

PATRYLIAK, I. K. (2004), Viiskova diialnist OUN(b) u 1940–1942 rokakh, Kyiv: Kyivskyi natsionalnyi universytet imeni Tarasa Shevchenka; Instytut istorii Ukrainy NAN Ukrainy.
Google Scholar

Perestoroha!, 1943. Oholoshennia Hubernatora Halytskoi Oblasti, Komanduvacha SS – i Politsii gez. Katzmann, Lviv, June, 3, 1943, Dnipro: Arkhiv Tsentru “Tkuma”.
Google Scholar

Poet M. Fishbein: dlia mene UPA – tse sviate, http://www.bbc.co.uk/ukrainian/indepth/story/2008/10/printable/081014_fishbein_ie_ak.shtml [accessed on: 20.04.2019].
Google Scholar

Pravedniki narodov mira (2008), [in:] LAKER, U. and BAUMEL, Yu. T. (eds.) Holokost: Jenciklopedija, translated from English, Moscow.
Google Scholar

Pravedniki narodov mira, Yad Vashem, http://www.yadvashem.org/yv/ru/righteous/faqs.asp [accessed on: 10.04.2019].
Google Scholar

Pravedniki narodov mira. Statistika, Yad Vashem, http://www.yadvashem.org/yv/ru/righteous/sta-tistics.asp [accessed on: 10.04.2019].
Google Scholar

REDLIKH, Sh. (2007), Moralnye printsipy v povsednevnoy deystvitelnosti: mitropolit Andrey Sheptitskiy i evrei v period Kholokosta i Vtoroy mirovoy voyny, http://www.jcrelations.net/%D0%A1%D1%82%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%BD%D0%B0.3180.0.html?L=7 [accessed on: 10.04.2019].
Google Scholar

REDLIKH, Sh. (2007), Razom i narizno v Berezhanakh: Poliaky, yevrei ta ukraintsi, 1919–1945, 2nd ed., translated from English, Kyiv.
Google Scholar

REDLIKH, Sh. (2010), Mitropolit Andrey Sheptitskiy i evrei v period Kholokosta i Vtoroy mirovoy voyny, http://www.cerkva.od.ua/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=594&Itemid=87 [accessed on: 10.04.2019].
Google Scholar

REDLIKH, Sh. (2011), ‘Sheptickij otrical rasistskoe myshlenie: (interv’ju professora Shimona Redliha zhurnalu “Tygodnik Povshehny” (Tygodnik Powszechny)’, http://www.newswe.com/index.php?go=Pages&in=view&id=3690 [accessed on: 10.04.2019].
Google Scholar

Righteous Among the Nations Honoured by Yad Vashem by 1 January 2017, Yad Vashem, http://www.yadvashem.org/yv/pdf-drupal/ukraine.pdf [accessed on: 15.04.2019].
Google Scholar

Shchodennyk Lvivskoho hetto: spohady rabyna Davyda Kakhane, (2009), KOVBA, Zh. (compiler), Kyiv.
Google Scholar

SHCHUPAK, I. Ya. (1997), ‘Otnoshenie ukrainskogo naselenija Zaporozh’ja k evrejam vo vremja vojny 1941–1945 gg.’, Zaporizhzhia Jewish Readings, 1, Zaporizhzhia.
Google Scholar

SHCHUPAK, I. (2007), ‘Mytropolyt Andrei Sheptytskyi: osobystist ta symvol v istorii’, Problems of the Holocaust History: Scientific Journal, 4, pp. 88–99.
Google Scholar

SHCHUPAK, I. Ya. (2012), ‘Trahediia yevreiv Ukrainy’, Natsionalne pytannia v Ukraini ХХ – pochatku ХХI st.: istorychni narysy, Red. rada: LYTVYN, V. M. (holova), BORIAK, H. V. and DANYLENKO, V. M. et al.; vidp. red. SMOLII, V. A. avt. kol.: ARKUSHA, O. H. VERSTIUK, V. F. and VIDNIANSKYI S. V. et al., Kyiv.
Google Scholar

SHCHUPAK, I. (2016), ‘Ukrainski riativnyky yevreiv pid chas Holokostu’, [in:] SHCHUPAK, I., Pravednyky narodiv svitu: Dovidnyk, Dnipro: Ukrainskyi instytut vyvchennia Holokostu “Tkuma”.
Google Scholar

SHCHUPAK, I. (2018), ‘Ryatuvannya ukrayintsyamy ta polyakamy yevreyiv Zakhidnoyi Ukrayiny pid chas Holokostu’, Skhidnoyevropeysʹkyy istorychnyy visnyk, 3, pp. 296–309.
Google Scholar

SIKORSKA, O. (2017), ‘Poryatunok yevreyiv u kolektyvniy pam’yati halychan na prykladi Uneva ta Univsʹkoyi Lavry’, Yevreysʹki istoriyi ukrayinsʹkykh tereniv. Ukrayina Moderna, 24, pp. 139–150.
Google Scholar

SKIRA, Y. (2017), Uchastʹ monakhiv studiysʹkoho ustavu u poryatunku yevreyiv na terytoriyi Lʹvivsʹkoyi Arkhiyeparkhiyi Hreko-katolytsʹkoyi tserkvy u 1942–1944 rr.: dis., thesis, Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine, Lviv Polytechnic National University; Institute of Ukrainian Studies, I. Krypyakevych of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Lviv.
Google Scholar

SKIRA, Y. (2019), ‘Perekhovuvannya Kurta Levina u monastyri Svyatoho svyashchennomuchenyka Yosafata u Lʹvovi pid chas Holokostu (na osnovi dokumentiv z arkhivu Svyatouspensʹkoyi Univsʹkoyi Lavry Studiysʹkoho Ustavu)’, [in:] Ukrayinsʹko-yevreysʹke spivzhyttya pid chas Holokostu. Na materiali Zakhidnoyi Ukrayiny, [in:] BOLIANOVSKYI, A. (ed.), Dnipro–Lviv: “Tkuma” Institute, Institute of Ukrainian Studies. I. Krypyakevych of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine; “Lira LTD”, pp. 161–170.
Google Scholar

SKIRA, Y. (2019), Poklykani: monakhy Studiysʹkoho Ustavu ta Holokost, Kyiv: Dukh i Litera.
Google Scholar

SNAIDER, T. (2011), Kryvavi zemli: Yevropa pomizh Hitlerom ta Stalinym: monohrafiia, Kyiv: Hrani-T.
Google Scholar

Ubili odnosel’chan, prjatavshih evreev. Akt. Har’kovskaja oblast’, Dergachevskij r-n, s. Semenovka, (1996), [in:] SVERDLOV, F. D. (compiler) and AL’TMAN, I. A. (ed.) Dokumenty obvinjajut. Holokost: svidetel’stva Krasnoj Armii, Moscow.
Google Scholar

VIATROVYCH, V. (2006), Stavlennia OUN do yevreiv: formuvannia pozytsii na tli katastrofy, Lviv: Vydavnytstvo “Ms”.
Google Scholar

VOYTUK, O. (2019), ‘Aktsiya Mytropolyta Andreya Sheptytsʹkoho i Hreko-Katolytsʹkoyi Tserkvy shchodo poryatunku yevreyiv (1941–1944 rr.)’, [in:] Ukrayinsʹko-yevreysʹke spivzhyttya pid chas Holokostu. Na materiali Zakhidnoyi Ukrayiny, BOLIANOVSKYI, A. (ed.) Dnipro–Lviv: “Tkuma” Institute, Institute of Ukrainian Studies. I. Krypyakevych of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine; “Lira LTD”, pp. 41–51.
Google Scholar

Vseukrainska yevreiska rada, http://jadvis.org.ua/component/k2/item/405 [accessed on: 10.04.2019].
Google Scholar

YEREMIEIEVA, I. and MYROPOLSKYI, V. (2019), ‘Problemy vyznannya pravednykamy narodiv svitu (na prykladi mytropolyta Andreya Sheptytsʹkoho)’, Molodyy vchenyy, 2 (66), pp. 393–397. https://doi.org/10.32839/2304-5809/2019-2-66-86
Google Scholar DOI: https://doi.org/10.32839/2304-5809/2019-2-66-86

ZILINSKYI, V. (2019), Holokost na terytoriyi dystryktu «Halychyna»: dzhereloznavchyy analiz problemy: dis., thesis, Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine, Ivan Franko National University of Lviv; The National Academy of Science of Ukraine; M. Hrushevsky Institute of Ukrainian Archeography and Source Studies, Lviv.
Google Scholar