‘Our Folk Who Have (Not) Become Foreign...’: Political Loyalties in the Donbas During the War of 2014‒2024 (In Light of Oral History Sources)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18778/3071-7779.2025.2.08Słowa kluczowe:
political loyalty, the Donbas, war, internally displaced persons, refugees, oral history sourcesAbstrakt
The military conflict that started in the Donbas in 2014, which, in 2022, turned into a full-scale Russo-Ukrainian war, has created a specific way in which it is remembered. This article is based on more than sixty interviews with residents of the Donbas and other regions of Ukraine who fled the country in the period between 2014 and 2024. It addresses the distinctive way in which the events of 2014–2024 affected the formation and evolution of political loyalties; characterises the key factors that have influenced the circumstances of the refugees; analyses the specifics of adaptation in a new place and the practicalities of interaction with the environment; and identifies key socio-political challenges that the region may face after the war.
The gathered recollections paint a complex picture of the political positioning of the Donbas populace in the context of the 2014–2024 war. Worldview attitudes formed over the years, propaganda influences from opposing sides, as well as the direct military experience of the region’s residents were crucial to the formation of different models of political loyalties. It is noteworthy that the decision to flee or to stay in the Donbas was determined by several factors, such as the physical security situation, family circumstances, opportunities for adaptation in a new place, the ability to find new accommodation and a job, fear of discrimination, political and ideological preferences, etc. Situations in which some refugees were forced to return home, to the combat zone, demonstrate a set of problems related to the lack of a consistent state policy towards this category of the population. It is emphasised that a fully representative depiction of the formation and evolution of the system of political loyalties requires that, in the future, the experiences of people who have left for Russia or Belarus and those who continue to live in the occupied territory should also be taken into account.
Bibliografia
Interview with a man, born in 1955, who lived in Mariupol. Place and time of the interview: Dortmund, 17 December 2023.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a man, born in 1962, who lived in Luhansk. Place and time of the interview: Heidelberg, 22 December 2023.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a man, born in 1963, who lived in Donetsk, later — Mariupol.Place and time of the interview: Poland, 15 February 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a man, born in 1980, who lived in Donetsk. Place and time of the interview: Heidelberg, 15 February 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a man, born in 2004, who lived in Chernihiv. Place and time of the interview: Heidelberg, 7 January 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman, born in 1946, who lived in Donetsk. Place and time of the interview: Heidelberg, 25 January 2024. Personal archive of the author.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman, born in 1968, who lived in Donetsk. Place and time of the interview: Heidelberg, 10 April 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman, born in 1969, who lived in Kramatorsk. Place and time of the interview: Zielona Góra, 17 February 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman, born in 1969, who lived in Mariupol. Place and time of the interview: Heidelberg, 11 February 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman, born in 1971, who lived in Donetsk. Place and time of the interview: Mannheim, 10 December 2023. Personal archive of the author.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman, born in 1971, who lived in Mariupol. Place and time of the interview: Rütten, 16 December 2023.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman, born in 1976, who lived in Donetsk. Place and time of the interview: Neuenkirchen, 15 January 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman 1, born in 1978, who lived in Donetsk. Place and time of interview: Heidelberg, 15 July 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman 2, born in 1978, who lived in Donetsk. Place and time of interview: Kryvyi Rih, 21 December 2019. Personal archive of the author.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman, born in 1979, lived in Bakhmut. Place and time of the interview: Halstenbek, 24 November 2023.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman, born in 1979, who lived in Sloviansk. Place and time of the interview: Halstenbek, 24 November 2023.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman, born in 1980, who lived in Donetsk. Place and time of the interview: Heidelberg, 17 January 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman, born in 1983, who lived in Mariupol. Place and time of the interview: Uelzen, 25 November 2023.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman 1, born in 1984, who lived in Donetsk. Place and time of the interview: Wrocław, 9 January 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman 2, born in 1984, who lived in Donetsk. Place and time of the interview: Berlin, 14 December 2023.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman, born in 1985, who lived in Kharkiv. Place and time of the interview: Heidelberg, 9 January 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman, born in 1988, who lived in Kramatorsk. Place and time of the interview: Munich, 18 January 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman, born in 1988, who lived in Mariupol. Place and time of the interview: Wilthen, 11 February 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman, born in 1991, who lived in Donetsk, after 2014 — in Dnipro. Place and time of interview: Heidelberg, 22 June 2024. Personal archive of the author.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman, born in 1992, who lived in Kramatorsk. Place and time of the interview: Zielona Góra, 17 February 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Interview with a woman, born in 2002, who lived in Kharkiv. Place and time of interview: Neuenkirchen, 25 January 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
2022. Country Reports on Human Rights Practices: Ukraine. https://www.state.gov/reports/2022-country-reports-on-human-rights-practices/ukraine. Available online: 1 October 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
24.02.22, 5 am: Testimonies from the war. https://www.lvivcenter.org/en/researches/oral-testimonies-from-the-war-2/. Available online: 20 September 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Assejev S. 2020. In Isolation. Texte aus dem Donbass. Berlin.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Barva M., Bilokobylskyi O., Irpinskyi O., Moskalenko A., Petrenko A., Pihurska T., Proskurnia V., Chystiakova Yu. 2024. Prymarna yasnist: mify i stereotypy navkolo Donbasu i viiny. In: O. Bilokobylskyi, N. Nesterenko (eds), Kyiv.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Bizhentsi vtrachaiut zviazok z Ukrainoiu. Shcho pokazaly doslidzhennia. https://www.bbc.com/ukrainian/articles/cprggynrp38o. Available online: 12 September 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Chyselnist naselennia na 1 sichnia 2014 roku ta serednia chyselnist za 2013 rik. https://www.ukrstat.gov.ua/operativ/operativ2014/ds/kn/kn_u/kn0114_u.html. Available online: 20 September 2023.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Conflict-related civilian casualties in Ukraine. https://ukraine.un.org/sites/default/files/2022-02/Conflict-related%20civilian%20casualties%20as%20of%2031%20December%202021%20%28rev%2027%20January%202022%29%20corr%20EN_0.pdf. Available online: 17 September 2023.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Gulina O. 2015. Nie wieder Krieg, Flüchtlinge aus der Ukraine. “Osteuropa” 4, 132–142.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Gyidel E. 2022. Ukrainian Internally Displaced Persons and the Future of Donbas. In: J. Hauter (ed.), The war in Ukraine’s Donbas. Origins, Contexts, and the Future. Budapest–Vienna–New York, 109–121.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Hellbeck J., Pastushenko T., Tytarenko D. 2017. ‘Wir werden siegen, wie schon vor 70 Jahren unsere Großväter gesiegt haben’. Weltkriegsgedenken in der Ukraine im Schatten des neuerlichen Kriegs. In: M. Gabowitsch, C. Gdaniec, E. Makhotina (eds), Kriegsgedenken als Event. Der 9. Mai im postsozialistischen Europa, 41–66.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Khanstantynov V.O. 2014. Politychna loialnist i rol elity v yii formuvanni. “Naukovyi chasopys Natsionalnoho pedahohichnoho universytetu im. M.P. Drahomanova”, Ser. 22, Issue 15, 60–66.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Kononov I.F. 2016. Luhanskyi syndrom yak masova anomichna reaktsiia na rozghortannia hibrydnoi viiny http://www.historians.in.ua/index.php/en/doshdzhennya/1778-inya-kononov-luhanskyy-syndrom-yak-masova-anomichna-reaktsiyana-rozhortannya-hibrydnoyi-viyny. Available online: 23 April 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Mitrokhin N. 2020. Infiltration, Instruction, Invasion. Russia’s War in the Donbas. In: J. Hauter (ed.), Civil war? Interstate war? Hybrid war? Dimensions and Interpretations of the Donbas Conflict in 2014–2020, 113–144.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Monitorynh kontrolnykh punktiv v’izdu-vyizdu na skhodi Ukrainy (1 pivrichchia 2019). 2019. Ahentstvo OON u spravakh bizhentsiv, BF ‘Pravo na zakhyst’. https://archive.r2p.org.ua/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/EECP-Survey-Report-1-quarter-2019-eng-2.pdf. Available online: 20 October 2023.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Museum of Civilian Voices, founded by the Rinat Akhmetov Foundation. https://civilvoicesmuseum.org/en. Available online: 22 April 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Mykhailov D. Zakonodavstvo pro kolaboratsionizm ne vidpovidae mizhnarodnomu humanitarnomu pravu — ZMINA. https://suspilne.media/802683-zakonodavstvo-pro-kolaboracionizm-ne-vidpovidae-miznarodnomu-gumanitarnomu-pravu-zmina/. Available online: 10 September 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Nahorna S. 2008. Rehionalna identychnist: ukrainskyi kontekst. Kyiv.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Natsionalna sudova praktyka z pytan vnutrishnoho peremishchennia: zastosuvannia standartiv Rady Yevropy. 2019. Kyiv.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Natsionalnyi sklad naselennia Ukrainy ta yoho movni oznaky za danymy Vseukrainskoho perepysu naselennia 2001 r. 2003. Kyiv.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Overview of the Human Rights Situation in Ukraine. 1 February – 30 April 2023. https://www.ohchr.org/ru/documents/country-reports/hrmmu-update-human-rights-situation-ukraine-1-february-2023–30-april-2023. Available online: 15 October 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Pres-reliz: Opytuvannia ukrainskykh bizhentsiv u Nimechchyni, Polshchi ta Chekhii: zadovolenist zhyttiam zakordonom, povernennia v Ukrainu, interes do sytuatsii v Ukraini (20–26 kvitnia 2024 roku). https://kiis.com.ua/?lang=ukr&cat=reports&id=1408&page=1. Available online: 10 September 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Schäfer K. 2024. Internally Displaced Persons in Ukraine. National Belonging in the Light of the Ongoing Donbas Conflict. Baden-Baden.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Schuller K. 2016. Warten und sterben. “Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung”. 17 November.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Sotsiolohichne doslidzhennia do Dnia nezalezhnosti: uiavlennia pro patriotyzm ta maibutnie Ukrainy (16–20 serpnia 2023). https://www.ratinggroup.ua/news/soc-olog-chne-dosl-dzhennya-do-dnya-nezalezhno-uyavlennya-pro-patr-otizm-ta-maybutn-ukra-ni-16-20-se. Available online: 12 September 2024.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Tytarenko D. 2021. ‘Detstvo pryshlos na voinu – vydat, v voinu prydetsia y umeret...’ svidky Druhoi svitovoi /Velykoi Vitchyznianoi viiny v umovakh voiennoho konfliktu na Donbasi. In: Slukhaty, chuty, rozumity. Usna istoriia Ukrainy XX–XXI stolit. Kyiv, 146–179.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Tytarenko O. 2017. Voiennyi dosvid ditei Donbasu: vyklyk dlia suspilstva. In: Suchasni suspilni problemy u vymiri sotsiolohii upravlinnia. Materialy XIII Vseukrainskoi naukovo-praktychnoi konferentsii, Mariupol, 3 bereznia 2017 r. Mariupol, 225–229.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Uehling G. 2023. Everyday War. The Conflict over Donbas, Ukraine. Ithaca–London.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Vdoskonalennia natsionalnoho zakonodavstva Ukrainy stosovno zakhystu prav liudyny vnutrishno peremishchenykh osib. Perehlianutyi bazovyi analiz. 2019. Kharkiv.
Zobacz w Google Scholar
Pobrania
Opublikowane
Jak cytować
Numer
Dział
Licencja
Utwór dostępny jest na licencji Creative Commons Uznanie autorstwa – Użycie niekomercyjne – Bez utworów zależnych 4.0 Międzynarodowe.
